Borchers v. Fifth Third Bank, Unpublished Decision (7-12-2000)
Borchers v. Fifth Third Bank, Unpublished Decision (7-12-2000)
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff-appellee Richard T. Borchers ran a business out of his home and maintained a checking account with defendant-appellant Fifth Third Bank. In May 1998, James Smith, an acquaintance and former employee, came to Borchers's home. Unbeknownst to Borchers, while Smith was there, he stole a booklet of blank checks from Borchers's desk. Shortly thereafter, Borchers became concerned when he noticed that the balance on his account was unexplainably low. Upon contacting Fifth Third, he was instructed by an employee to wait until his next statement arrived. When Borchers received the statement approximately two weeks later, he examined it and discovered that eight checks that he had not written, all paid to James Smith, had been charged to his account. Borchers immediately contacted Fifth Third and reported the matter. Following an investigation, it was determined that Smith had stolen the checks from Borchers's home, had forged Borchers's signature as the drawer and listed himself as the payee, and had cashed the checks at Fifth Third banking centers where the tellers had failed to verify the authenticity of the drawer's signature.
In December 1998, after Fifth Third had refused to reimburse the $2,305 charged to his account as the result of its improper payment of the checks, Borchers filed a suit for negligence and conversion. In its answer, Fifth Third asserted as a defense, pursuant to R.C.
Fifth Third asserts that the magistrate applied the incorrect legal standard in ruling on its statutory defense. It argues that the magistrate applied a negligence standard rather than the ordinary-care standard provided in R.C.
Although Fifth Third is correct in arguing that, under the amended version of R.C.
Further, a certified copy of this Judgment Entry shall constitute the mandate, which shall be sent to the trial court under App.R. 27. Costs shall be taxed under App.R. 24.
Doan, P.J., Gorman and Sundermann, JJ.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.