State v. Fleming, Unpublished Decision (6-16-2000)
State v. Fleming, Unpublished Decision (6-16-2000)
Opinion of the Court
Although we find his other contentions to be without merit, we agree with Fleming that the trial court incorrectly deemed itself obligated to consider the factors prescribed by R.C.
THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE R.C. §
2950.09 (B)(2), WHICH PRESCRIBES FACTORS FOR THE TRIAL COURT TO CONSIDER IN ADJUDICATING THE QUESTIONS OF FACT WHETHER AN OFFENDER IS LIKELY TO ENGAGE IN THE FUTURE IN ONE OR MORE SEXUALLY ORIENTED OFFENSES, ENCROACHES UPON THE JUDICIAL POWER, IN VIOLATION OF THE SEPARATION OF POWERS IMPLICIT IN THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.
Fleming's sexual offender classification hearing was held before our decision in State v. White, supra. Accordingly, it is not surprising that the trial court deemed itself required to consider the factors prescribed in R.C.
In State v. White, supra, we held that: "[I]t is beyond the constitutional power of the General Assembly to prescribe particular factors that a trial judge must consider when finding a fact." Accordingly, on the authority of State v. White, supra, Fleming's First Assignment of Error is sustained.
THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180, PROVIDES NO GUIDANCE AS TO HOW THE FACTORS IN R.C. §
2950.09 (B)(2) ARE TO BE CONSIDERED AND WEIGHED, RENDERING THE LAW VAGUE, IN VIOLATION OF THE DUE PROCESS CLAUSES OF THEFOURTEENTH AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND SECTION16 , ARTICLEI OF THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180, IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AS APPLIED TO MR. FLEMING, WHOSE OFFENSES WERE COMMITTED PRIOR TO THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE AMENDMENTS. THE RETROACTIVE APPLICATION OF R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180, VIOLATES THE EX POST FACTO CLAUSE OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. WILLIAM FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE THE REGISTRATION PROVISIONS OF R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180, CONSTITUTE CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT, IN VIOLATION OF THE
EIGHTH AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND SECTION9 , ARTICLE1 OF THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE THE APPLICATION OF R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180 AND AS APPLIED TO MR. FLEMING, CONSTITUTES DOUBLE JEOPARDY IN VIOLATION OF THE
FIFTH ANDFOURTEENTH AMENDMENTS TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND SECTION10 , ARTICLEI OF THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.
As the State notes, each of these constitutional attacks upon the sexual offender classification statute was rejected in State v. Cook (1998),
THE TRIAL COURT COMMITTED ERROR IN LABELING MR. FLEMING A SEXUAL PREDATOR AND A HABITUAL SEXUAL OFFENDER BECAUSE R.C. CHAPTER 2950, AS AMENDED BY H.B. 180, IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN ITS ENTIRETY IN VIOLATION OF SECTIONS
1 AND2 , ARTICLEI OF THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.
The argument that a sexual predator or habitual sexual offender classification unduly restricts the offender's personal liberty, in violation of Section
We conclude that sexual offenders are not a suspect class, requiring heightened scrutiny. We further conclude that the creation of various reporting and registration requirements for certain kinds of sexual offenders bears a rational relationship to a legitimate government objective, since these requirements facilitate notice to persons who may come in contact with the former offender in their neighborhood, in order that they and their children may be appropriately cautious in interacting socially with the former sexual offender.
Fleming's Sixth Assignment of Error is overruled.
GRADY, P.J., and BROGAN J., concur.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.