Sostre v. McFaul, Unpublished Decision (6-29-2000)
Sostre v. McFaul, Unpublished Decision (6-29-2000)
Opinion of the Court
In State of Ohio v. Melvin Sostre, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Case No. Cr. 356868, the court sentenced Mr. Sostre in March 1998 to a total of ten months for convictions of grand theft and forgery. The court imposed this sentence consecutively to a sentence which Mr. Sostre was already serving. He was released in June 1999, but the Ohio Adult Parole Authority placed him on post-release control pursuant to R.C.
Subsequently, the grand jury indicted him for a December 1999 charge of having a weapon under disability, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Case No. C.R. 387460. Mr. Sostre maintains that he could post bond and be released from jail for the new charge, but the Ohio Adult Parole Authority has placed a hold on him for breaking his post-release control from Case No. C.R. 356868. Consequently, he remains in jail.
Mr. Sostre argues that this imprisonment for breaking post-release control is unauthorized because this court declared R.C.
The respondents argue that habeas relief should not issue because they are lawfully detaining Mr. Sostre pursuant to R.C.
Moreover, this court's holding in Jones should not be given effect, because the Supreme Court of Ohio has accepted jurisdiction of Jones in Supreme Court of Ohio Case No. 99-1881 and has stayed the execution of this court's judgment in that case. By staying the judgment in Jones, the supreme court also stayed this court's determination that R.C.
The respondents' argument is persuasive. Mr. Sostre does not contest it, and thus he has not established that he is entitled to his immediate release from jail. Moreover, in State v.Hochhausler (1996),
Accordingly, the respondents' motions to dismiss are granted, and this habeas corpus action is dismissed. Petitioner to pay costs.
ANN DYKE, A.J., and TERRENCE O'DONNELL, J., CONCUR.
___________________________ PATRICIA ANN BLACKMON JUDGE
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.