City of Uhrichsville v. Losey, Unpublished Decision (12-7-2005)
City of Uhrichsville v. Losey, Unpublished Decision (12-7-2005)
Opinion of the Court
OPINION
{¶ 1} Appellant Kevin Losey appeals his conviction for domestic violence in the County Court, Tuscarawas County. The relevant facts leading to this appeal are as follows.{¶ 2} On October 21, 2004, Uhrichsville police officers responded to a domestic call at the West Second Street residence of appellant and his live-in girlfriend, Tonya Devore. Upon arrival, the officers observed Tonya with a bloody nose and a red mark above her left eye. Tonya told one of the officers that appellant, who appeared intoxicated, "had just beat her up and threatened to kill her." Tr. at 22. The incident was overheard by Tonya's teenage niece, who testified at the subsequent trial.
{¶ 3} Appellant was arrested and charged with domestic violence, R.C.
{¶ 4} The court found appellant guilty of domestic violence. On March 1, 2005, appellant was sentenced to thirty days in jail, with all days suspended subject to community control sanctions. On March 30, 2005, appellant filed a notice of appeal. He herein raises the following three Assignments of Error:
{¶ 5} "I. THE DEFENSE PROVED BY A PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE OF SELF-DEFENSE.
{¶ 6} "II. THE STATE DID NOT SHOW BY ANY EVIDENCE THAT THE ELEMENT OF LIVING AS A SPOUSE WAS PROVEN.
{¶ 7} "III. THE ACCUSED COULD NOT BE CONVICTED OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE DUE TO THE PASSAGE OF THE DEFENSE OF MARRIAGE AMENDMENT TO THE OHIO CONSTITUTION."
{¶ 9} Self defense is a "confession and avoidance" affirmative defense in which the defendant admits the elements of the crime but seeks to prove some additional element which absolves the defendant of guilt. State v. White (Jan. 14, 1998), Ross App. No. 97 CA 2282. The affirmative defense of self-defense places the burden of proof on a defendant by a preponderance of the evidence. In re Collier (Aug. 30, 2001), Richland App. No. 01 CA 5, citing State v. Caldwell (1992),
{¶ 10} During the trial in the case sub judice, Tonya, the victim, testified that she and appellant had been arguing on the evening of October 21, 2004, and that appellant was getting upset because she "wouldn't leave him alone" despite his need to get up very early the next morning. Tr. at 5. Tonya recalled that she left the bedroom by slamming the door "real hard," at which time appellant followed her outside the bedroom and shoved her. Id. Tonya began approaching him, at which point appellant shoved her again, causing her to fall onto the bed, resulting in her kicking him in the chest. Id. Appellant then held her down on the bed, covering her face with at least one of his hands. Tr. at 6. Appellant told her "that he could kill me if I would not leave him alone." Tr. at 15. Tonya conceded that her nose was bleeding when help arrived. Tr. at 7.
{¶ 11} During his defense testimony, appellant stated he had pulled the door open after Tonya slammed it, and that he then shoved her. He continued:
{¶ 12} "I went back in the bedroom. At that time, she came in, pushed the door open again, I shoved it back in her face, I said leave me the fuck alone. The door flung open again. At that time, she marched towards me and here's the bed, here's the door, she marched towards me, she hit the side of the wall like that, she shoved me. I just pull her like this and threw her on the bed, I said fucking quit it and I went like that and she kicked me in the chest against the dresser. At that time, I jumped on her. Now they're saying I didn't restrain her arms, her legs, or nothing like that. I don't know if you guys, either one of them, have ever wrestled or anybody in this courtroom has wrestled, what I did was I took this arm, she had her arm like this, I grabbed her arm like that, I had her on the bed like this and I put my hand on her mouth, some common wrestling move. I also locked my legs around her legs so she couldn't move." Tr. at 28-29.
{¶ 13} Appellant also admitted to "apparently" bloodying Tonya's nose. Tr. at 31.
{¶ 14} Upon review of the record, we conclude the trial court would not have erred under these facts and circumstances in finding that appellant failed to show (1) he was not at fault in creating the situation via his initial "shoving" acts and (2) he believed he was in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm from Tonya. Robbins, supra. We are therefore not inclined to reverse the trial court's rejection of the affirmative defense of self-defense. Appellant's First Assignment of Error is overruled.
{¶ 16} Under R.C.
{¶ 17} "Q. How long has [appellant] resided there?
{¶ 18} "A. We moved in in August together.
{¶ 19} "Q. August of —
{¶ 20} "A. This year.
{¶ 21} "Q. 2004?
{¶ 22} "A. This year.
{¶ 23} "Q. Okay. So you've been living together for a couple of months?
{¶ 24} "A. At this residence, yeah, but we've been together a year and-a-half.
{¶ 25} "Q. Okay. You've been living together a year and-a-half?
{¶ 26} "A. Yes." Tr. at 4.
{¶ 27} We find this testimony is sufficient to establish that Tonya was a family or household member in regard to appellant for purposes of the domestic violence statute. Cf. State v.Williams, Stark App. No. 2002CA00428,
{¶ 28} Appellant's Second Assignment of Error is therefore overruled.
{¶ 30} The Defense of Marriage Amendment, which was adopted by the voters of Ohio on November 2, 2004, is found in Section
{¶ 31} "Only a union between one man and one woman may be a marriage valid in or recognized by this state and its political subdivisions. This state and its political subdivisions shall not create or recognize a legal status for relationships of unmarried individuals that intends to approximate the design, qualities, significance or effect of marriage."
{¶ 32} This Court rejected an argument analogous to appellant's present contention in State v. Newell, Stark App. No. 2004CA00264,
{¶ 33} For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the County Court of Tuscarawas County, Ohio, is hereby affirmed.
Wise, J. Farmer, P.J., and Edwards, J., concur.
Costs to appellant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- City of Uhrichsville v. Kevin Losey
- Cited By
- 8 cases
- Status
- Unpublished