Ohio Court of Appeals, 2016

Kinderdine v. Alleman

Kinderdine v. Alleman
Ohio Court of Appeals · Decided August 19, 2016 · No. 14 MA 0177 · DeGenaro
2016 Ohio 5481
Kinderdine v. Alleman

Opinion

[Cite as Kinderdine v. Alleman, 2016-Ohio-5481.]

STATE OF OHIO, MAHONING COUNTY IN THE COURT OF APPEALS SEVENTH DISTRICT

TRACY KINDERDINE, et al. ) )

PLAINTIFF-APPELLANTS ) ) CASE NO. 2014 MA 0177 VS. ) ) OPINION BREANNA ALLEMAN ) AND ) JUDGMENT ENTRY DEFENDANT-APPELLEE )

CHARACTER OF PROCEEDINGS: Motion for Reconsideration JUDGMENT: Denied.

JUDGES:

Hon. Mary DeGenaro

Hon. Cheryl L. Waite

Hon. Carol Ann Robb

Dated: August 19, 2016

APPEARANCES:

For Plaintiff-Appellants Attorney W. Craig Bashein

Attorney Anthony N. Palombo

BASHEIN & BASHEIN CO., L.P.A.

Terminal Tower, 35th Floor

50 Public Square

Cleveland, Ohio 44113

Attorney Paul Flowers

PAUL W. FLOWERS CO., L.P.A.

Terminal Tower, 35th Floor

50 Public Square

Cleveland, Ohio 44113

Attorney Thomas J. Wilson

COMSTOCK, SPRINGER & W ILSON CO., L.P.A.

100 Federal Plaza East, Suite 926 Youngstown, Ohio 44503-1811

For Defendant-Appellee Attorney Joseph M. Ruscak

ROETZEL & ANDRESS, L.P.A.

222 South Main Street

Akron, Ohio 44308

Attorney Matthew John Markling Attorney Patrick Vrobel

Attorney Sean Koran

MCGOWN & MARKLING CO., L.P.A.

1894 North Cleveland-Massillon Road Akron, Ohio 44333 [Cite as Kinderdine v. Alleman, 2016-Ohio-5481.]

PER CURIAM.

{¶1} Tracy Kinderdine, et al., Plaintiff-Appellants, filed a motion for reconsideration in the appeal of Kinderdine et al., v. Breanna Alleman, 7th Dist. No. MA 0174, 0177, 0180, 0181, 2016-Ohio-4815. {¶2} "The test generally applied upon the filing of a motion for reconsideration in the court of appeals is whether the motion calls to the attention of the court an obvious error in its decision, or raises an issue for consideration that was either not considered at all or was not fully considered by the court when it should have been." Columbus v. Hodge, 37 Ohio App.3d 68, 523 N.E.2d 515 (1987), paragraph one of the syllabus. {¶3} The purpose of reconsideration is not to reargue one's appeal based on dissatisfaction with the logic used and conclusions reached by an appellate court. Victory White Metal Co. v. N.P. Motel Syst. Inc., 7th Dist. No. 04 MA 0245, 2005– Ohio–3828, ¶ 2. "An application for reconsideration may not be filed simply on the basis that a party disagrees with the prior appellate court decision." Hampton v. Ahmed, 7th Dist. No. 02 BE 0066, 2005–Ohio–1766, ¶ 16 (internal citation omitted). Nor is it "a mechanism to raise an entirely new argument and issue to the appellate court that was not raised in the appellate brief." State v. Wellington, 7th Dist. No. 14 MA 0115, 2015-Ohio-2095, ¶ 9. {¶4} The Kinderdines allege that this Court failed to apply the correct standard for reviewing a judgment on the pleadings. We held: In light of the disposition of our resolution of the Kinderdines' appeal of the trial court's grant of summary judgment in favor of Callos, the merits of this appeal are moot. App.R. 12(B). The Kinderdines asserted in their complaint against Alleman that she was acting within the scope of her employment. As Alleman was an employee of ESC, pursuant to the loan servant doctrine, she is immune from liability pursuant to R.C. 2744.03(A)(5). Further, the Kinderdines have failed to meet their burden of proof, making conclusory allegations rather than alleging operative facts demonstrating that Alleman acted in a willful, wanton or reckless manner. R.C. 2744.03(A)(6)(b).

Kinderdine, ¶ 34 {¶5} The Kinderdines' arguments regarding Alleman's liability were fully considered by this Court prior to ruling on the matter. The Kinderdines' motion for reconsideration does not call to the attention of the court an obvious error, but merely a disagreement with the decision reached by the Court. Accordingly, the Kinderdines' motion for reconsideration is denied.

DeGenaro, J., concurs.

Waite, J., concurs.

Robb, J., concurs.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.