Patty v. Mansfield
Opinion of the Court
Opinion of the court, by
The defense relied upon by the special plea in the bar in this case, is grounded upon sections 6 and 7 of the act of March 1,
In section 7, the oath to be taken by the jury so summoned is prescribed, and the judgment to be rendered on their finding. If the right of property is'found to be in the claimant, judgment *shall be rendered in his favor against the plaintiff iñ execution for costs, and also that he have restitution of the goods and chattels claimed; but if, on the other hand, the right of property is found to be in the claimant, then judgment shall be rendered against him for costs. The section then is concluded by the following proviso: “ That such judgment for the claimant as aforesaid shall be a justification to the officer in returning nulla bona to the writ of execution, by virtue of which the levy had been made as to such part of the goods and chattels as were found to belong to such claimant.”
There is no difficulty in cases where the jury find the right of property in the claimant. It then becomes the duty of the office^ to deliver to him the goods and chattels found to be his, and he will be protected against any claim on the part of a judgment creditor by a return of nulla bona. Thus far the statute is explicit. But if the right of property is not found to be in a claimant, the officer must of course retain it in his possession until sold in due course of law. As the statute does not specifically declare
The proceedings under the statute, however, will not conclude the claimant so far as persons, other than the officer, are concerned. If the right of property is really in him, that right will not be destroyed by a levy and sale. He may pursue it in the hands of a purchaser at sheriff’s sale, or he may, in a proper state of case, and in an appropriate action, proceed against the plaintiff in execution, or his agents, or any other person who may have improperly interfered.
The plea in the case under consideration, although somewhat ^defective in form, shows that the property in controversy was levied upon by execution; that it was claimed by the plaintiff; that at his request there was a trial of the right to the property, which was found not to be in the claimant, and judgment accordingly. We think the facts as substantially set forth constitute a delcnse to the action.
The demurrer is therefore overruled, and the cause continued and remanded to the Supreme Court of Miami county .for further proceedings.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.