Amazon Insurance v. Wall
Opinion of the Court
There is some conflict in the testimony, but it can serve no useful purpose to discuss the evidence in the report of a case. The facts established by the clear weight of testimony are as set forth in the foregoing statement.
Counsel for plaintiff in error have insisted, from some expressions in the testimony of the agent, Parker, that at the time he consented to the assignment of the policy to Wall, he was not informed that Gillespie had already taken a mortgage on the Champaign county land in lieu of his mortgage on the mill; and it is urged that the company was in this way improperly deprived of its right of subrogation, and hence there should be no recovery in this action. But we are of opinion that the agent consented to the assignment with full knowledge of all the facts, and therefore we are relieved from any consideration of the doctrine of subrogation.
The strongest objection to a recovery, no doubt, is, that the property was sold and conveyed to Wall; that Gillespie accepted a mortgage from Hamilton, on a farm in Champaign county, in lieu of his mortgage on the mill; ■that this was done without the knowledge or assent of the insurance company or its agent; that by the terms of the policy it became void when there was a change in the title or possession of the property; and that where a policy is
There was no necessity for a reformation of the policy. As to the mistake on the face of the instrument, that the risk commenced in 1876 and terminated in 1877, the error is apparent from other parts of the instrument and the time of'its delivery. Manifestly, 1875 and 1876 were intended; and, indeed, this is admitted. By the application of the plainest principles, such mistakes will be disregarded. Wood on Ins., sec. 207. Nor is it necessary to reform the instrument so as to apply to the interest of ■ Wall as owner. There was no mistake. It was agreed .that the policy should stand for the interest of Wall as
Motion overruled.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.