Scott v. McCullough
Scott v. McCullough
Opinion of the Court
The question to be determined is whether territory already comprised in a special school district may be included in another special school district.
The civil township is the basis of our school system. Land in each township was donated by the national government to the inhabitants of such township for the use of schools. For surveying the Northwest Territory congress adopted a new system of surveying. This system may be briefly described as the rectangular system. The territory was surveyed into townships six miles square. Each township was divided into thirty-six sections one mile square, and, under the system of numbering, section sixteen was as nearly as any other in the center of the township.
By section 7 of the act of 1802, which authorized the people of the eastern division of the Northwest Territory to form a constitution and a state government, congress proposed that section 16 in every township “shall be granted to the inhabitants of such township for the use of schools. ’ ’ The proposition was accepted by a resolution passed November 29, 1802, by the constitutional convention, on condition that a like donation, amounting to about one
Special districts were established by vote of the people under legislative authority or by special legislation, and were governed by the provisions of the act under which they were created. But prior to the act of 1873 (70 O. L., 195), special school districts were not recognized as a part of the common school system. By that act they were included as a part
“A special school district may be formed of any contiguous territory, not included within the limits of an incorporated city or village, which has a total tax valuation of not less than one hundred thousand dollars. To establish a special school district, a petition signed by not less than ten male citizens who are electors of the proposed special district shall be filed in the office of the probate judge of the county in which such special district is situated, or if said district is situated in two or more counties, then with the probate judge of the county having the greatest total tax valuation in said proposed district; said petition shall set forth the' desires of the petitioners, shall contain a description of the territory to be included in the proposed special district, and shall be accompanied by a statement giving the total tax valuation of said territory certified to by the county auditor or auditors and also an accurate map of the territory to be included in said district, the same to be prepared to the satisfaction of the probate judge; said petition shall also be accompanied by an undertaking of one or more of the petitioners, with security to the satisfaction of the judge, in the sum of one hundred dollars, conditioned that the parties entering into the undertaking shall pay all the costs of the proceedings if a special school district is not created, and in sueb case the probate judge shall render judgment against "the*543 parties to the undertaking for all the costs of the proceedings. In case the petition is granted the costs shall be taxed against the special school district thereby authorized and shall be paid by the board of education of said special school district, thereafter elected, from any funds that may come into its possession. A remonstrance signed by one or more of the male citizens who are electors of the proposed district may be filed with the probate judge and shall be considered on the hearing of the petition.”
The section then provides that nothing therein contained shall be construed to abolish any special school district then in existence. Section 3929 of the Revised Statutes, as enacted in said code, is as follows:
“Upon the filing of a petition in the probate court for the establishment of a special school district, the judge thereof shall fix a time for the hearing of the same, which shall be within sixty days of the filing thereof; he shall thereupon cause to be published for four consecutive weeks, in two newspapers of opposite politics, printed and of general circulation in the county where the petition is' filed, notice of the filing of such petition and the time of the hearing thereon; such notices shall also be mailed to the clerk or clerks of the board or boards of education having territory in the proposed special school district. The probate judge is authorized to hear and determine the question of the establishment of such special school district, may subpoena and examine witnesses under oath, may change the boundaries of the proposed special school district, shall fix and determine the amount of money due and payable to said special district1 from the surplus money in the treas*544 ury or in process of collection in the district or districts from which it was formed, or in case of the indebtedness of snch district or districts, he shall determine the amount of money due and payable by the special school district to the district or districts from which it was formed, and in either case the amount so ‘found due shall be [a] valid and binding obligation upon the board of education of such district or districts. The fees in cases involving the establishment of special school districts shall be the same as in civil cases, and the jurisdiction of the probate court in such cases shall be exclusive. ’ ’
The contention of defendants .in error is that section 3928 in express terms provides that a special school district may be formed of any contiguous territory, which has a total tax valuation of not less than one hundred thousand dollars, and is not included within the limits of an incorporated city or village, and that, as the act in terms exempts territory included within the limits of any incorporated city or village, any constructive exemption is precluded. But sections 3894, 3895 and 3935 are in pari materia with section 3928. Section 3894 provides that a part, or the whole, of any school district may be transferred to an adjoining school district by the mutual consent of the boards of education having control of such districts. Section 3895 provides that if the boards of education interested in the transfer of territory from one district to another fail or refuse to transfer territory by mutual consent, as provided for in section 3894, within sixty days after a petition therefor, signed by not less than one-half of the qualified male citizens who are electors residing in the territory sought to be transferred, is filed with the clerks of the boards, the petitioners may file a
If part of one district may be embraced in another, then part of the latter may be taken for another, and so on as long as other provisions of the statutes may be complied with, and with such consequences as make it unreasonable to assume that such a possibility was within the contemplation of the legislature.
The expediency of establishing the Adams Mills special school district and the alleged injustice of it to the remainder of Virginia township, are not questions for our consideration. The probate judge is authorized to hear and determine the question of the establishment of the district, and his- jurisdiction is made exclusive. If the results are not in but against the interests of the school system the remedy is with the legislature.
The judgments of the circuit court, of the court of common pleas, and of the probate court, are reversed.
Reversed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.