McCormick v. Sells Co.
McCormick v. Sells Co.
Opinion of the Court
Section 6584, Revised Statutes, in the Justices’ Code of Civil Procedure, prescribes the mode of appeal from the judgment of a justice of the peace to the court of common pleas, and does not except parties, who are such in a fiduciary capacity and háve given bond in this state, and who appeal in the interest of their trust, from the requirements of notice and bond for appeal. In Section 5228, Revised Statutes, in the chapter relating to civil procedure in the court of common pleas, it is provided that: “A party in any trust capacity, who 'has given bond in this state with sureties according to law, shall not be required to give -bond and security to perfect an appeal,” and in Section 6408, Revised Statutes, in a chapter relating to civil procedure in probate courts, it is provided that: “When the person appealing, from any judgment or order in any court, or before any tribunal, is a party in a fiduciary capacity, in which he has given bond within the state, for the faithful discharge of his duties, and appeals in the interest of the trust, he shall not
In Thomas, Admr. v. Moore, etc., 52 Ohio St., 200, it is decided that a party in' a fiduciary capacity to a case in the justice’s court, and who has given bond in this state, is not relieved bjr Section 6408 from giving bond for appeal from a justice’s court when the appeal is not in the interest of his trust, and in Browne, Assignee, v. Wallace, Assignee, et al., 66 Ohio St., 57, it is held that to perfect an appeal under 6408, Revised Statutes, a separate written notice to the court of an intention to appeal is necessary, and that a recital of notice in a journal entry is not sufficient. Ip the opinion in Thomas, Admr. v. Moore, supra, it is said that Section 6408, Revised Statutes, is applicable to appeals from justices of the peace and that Section 5228, Revised Statutes, is applicable onfy to appeals from the court of common' pleas to the circuit court; and in the opinion in Layer, Gdn. v. Schaber, Admr., 57 Ohio St., 234, it is said that Sections 5227 and 5228 apply to appeals from the common pleas court to the circuit court, and that Section 6408 applies to appeals from a probate court to the court of common pleas, and to appeals from other courts inferior to the court of conimon pleas. Unless some section other than 6408 applies, and unless these decisions are wrong, the judgments below are correct. Counsel for plaintiff in error contend that the statements referred to are merely obi-ter, that they are-based upon a mistaken view of the statutes, that Section 6408 is limited to appeals from the probate courts to courts of common pleas,
• Prior to the adoption of the present Constitution in 1851, probate courts did not exist in this state. In the administration act of 1840, 38 Ohio Laws, 146, S. & C., 563, Sec. CCLXIII, it is provided: “Every executor or administrator who may have given bond in this state, with- sureties, agreeable to law, shall be authorized in all cases of an appeal from one court to another, by him made, to prosecute the same without filing any appeal bond.'” This section remained in force until repealed in 1878, 75 Ohio Laws, 836-963, by an act, “To revisé and consolidate the laws relating to procedure in the probate court,” passed in pursuance of the plan that resulted in the Revised Statutes of 1880. Section 8 of Chapter *7 of the Act of 1878, 75.Ohio
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.