Ohio Supreme Court, 1924

Walter Coal Co. v. Cuyahoga Supply Co.

Walter Coal Co. v. Cuyahoga Supply Co.
Ohio Supreme Court · Decided February 23, 1924
2 Ohio Law. Abs. 213

Walter Coal Co. v. Cuyahoga Supply Co.

Opinion of the Court

For statement of facts in this case, see decision of Court of Appeals, post page-.

Defendant contends:

1. Defendant never agreed to sell “deep mined” coal. There was no meeting of the minds of the parties and therefore no contract. The modified acceptance of plaintiff constituted only a counter proposal.

2. The modified acceptance by plaintiffs of defendant’s offer was never assented to by defendant.

3. Plaintiff has not pleaded or shown any contract by defendant to deliver “deep mined” coal.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.