Ohio Supreme Court, 1950

State Ex Rel. Drexel v. Alvis

Ohio Supreme Court · Decided March 15, 1950 · Weygandt, Matthias, Hart, Zimmerman, Stewart, Turner, Taet

91 N.E.2d 22; 153 Ohio St. 244; 153 Ohio St. (N.S.) 244; 41 Ohio Op. 253; 1950 Ohio LEXIS 552 (North Eastern Reporter, Second Series)

Counsel

Miss Cecile J. Shapiro , for appellant. Mr. herbert S. Duffy. attorney general, and Mr. Alan E. Schwarzwalder , for appellee.

Opinion of the Court

*246 By the Court.

The judgment of the Court of Appeals is affirmed.

The petitioner is not unlawfully restrained, of his liberty by the sentence imposed on September 17, 1946, which commitment is not challenged in this proceeding. He is therefore in the lawful custody of the warden.

The sentence of October 23, 1946, may be voidable but it may not be attacked by habeas corpus as a substitute for appeal. Ex parte Shaw, 7 Ohio St., 81, 70 Am. Dec., 55; Ex parte Hagan, 25 Ohio St., 426; In re Allen, 91 Ohio St., 315, 110 N. E., 535.

The habitual criminal act is constitutional. Blackburn v. State, 50 Ohio St., 428, 36 N. E., 18; McDonald v. Massachusetts, 180 U. S., 311, 45 L. Ed., 542, 21 S. Ct., 389, affirming McDonald v. Commonwealth, 173 Mass., 322, 53 N. E., 574, 73 Am. St. Rep., 293.

Judgment affirmed.

Weygandt, C. J., Matthias, Hart, Zimmerman, Stewart, Turner and Taet, JJ., concur.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.