Terry v. Ely
Trial Court Opinion
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
WESTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA
MICHAEL TERRY, et al., ) )
Plaintiffs, ) ) v. ) Case No. CIV-19-990-D )
ROGER ELY, et al., ) )
Defendants. )
O R D E R
Before the Court is Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment [Doc. No. 36], filed pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56.1 Defendants Roger Ely, Vahid Salalati, and Four Horsemen Auto Group, Inc. assert that Plaintiffs cannot establish their remaining claims: 1) breach of a settlement agreement that obligated Defendants to negotiate for a resolution of any dispute with a nonparty lender, Southampton, Ltd.; and 2) breach of a non- disparagement clause in the settlement agreement by Defendant Ely based on statements made in insurance claim forms.2
It is undisputed that Plaintiff Michael Terry and Defendants entered into a written settlement agreement in September 2013. As part of the agreement, Four Horsemen Auto Group, Inc. “agree[d] to attempt to negotiate a resolution of any contractual dispute with Southampton, Ltd.” See Mot., Ex. 2 [Doc. No. 36-2] ¶ 2.10. The agreement contained a non-disparagement clause by which the parties “agree[d] to refrain from making any derogatory or detrimental comments about or concerning the other Parties.” Id. ¶ 2.11. After the agreement was made, Defendants through counsel engaged in discussions with Southampton, Ltd. to resolve their contractual disputes but were unsuccessful in reaching a resolution. See Salalati Aff. [Doc. No. 36-3] ¶¶ 5-6. In November 2014, nonparties to the settlement agreement – Chisholm Trail Auto Group, LLC and Chisholm Trail Auto Group II, LLC – submitted two proofs of loss for employee dishonesty coverage under their policy with Harco National Insurance Company. Defendant Ely signed the proofs of loss in a representative capacity on behalf of the insured entities, as required by the insurer’s form. See Defs.’ Mot., Ex. 4 [Doc. No. 36-4] at 2, 4 (ECF page numbering). To prevail on the breach of contract claim in Count 1, Plaintiffs must prove that “Defendants did not attempt to negotiate a resolution of any contractual disputes with Southampton, Ltd.” as required by the settlement agreement. See Compl. [Doc. No. 1], ¶ 31. The facts show that Defendants attempted to negotiate a resolution of contractual disputes with Southampton, Ltd. and so performed their obligation under the agreement.
Plaintiffs have not demonstrated any factual dispute on this issue. Therefore, Defendants are entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim in Count 1. To prevail on the breach of contract claim in Count 2, Plaintiffs must prove that Defendant Ely violated the disparagement clause by making statements about them in the proofs of loss. See Compl. ¶ 37. The insured limited liability companies (LLCs) submitted proofs of loss that made statements about Plaintiffs, but Defendant Ely was acting on behalf of the LLCs when he signed the forms. Plaintiffs have come forward with no evidence or legal authority for holding Defendant Ely personally responsible for any disparaging statements the LLCs made about Plaintiffs.3 Therefore, Defendant Ely is entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim against him.
For these reasons, the Court finds that Defendants are entitled to summary judgment on all remaining claims asserted against them in the Complaint.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment [Doc. No. 36] is GRANTED. A separate judgment shall be entered in their favor.
IT IS SO ORDERED this 1* day of July, 2021.
Q.Oyht
TIMOTHY D. DeGIUSTI
Chief United States District Judge
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.