Bayless v. McFarland
Bayless v. McFarland
Opinion of the Court
In this case there were two assignments of error, but they may both very properly be considered as one, to-wit: Was the order of the court dismissing the case for failure to comply with the conditions attached to the order allowing the plaintiff ito amend the affidavit in re-plevin, reversible error?
Now, there can be no doubt, that under our statute, the court, in granting leave to amend any pleading in the case, has the right to impose any reasonable terms and conditions. In tire case at bar, the conditions imposed on the plaintiff were, '(1st) that the amendment should be made within ten days; (2nd) that the plaintiff should pay all costs to date within ten days. Both of which condi-tins, under ordinary circumstances, would be reasonable, and we see no reason why such terms should not be considered reasonable in this case.
But these conditions apply only to plaintiff’s right to amend tlhe affidavit in replevin; in other words, his right to amend was dependent upon this condition precedent, namely, that he should amend within ten days. Now, what, by reasonable contruction of the language of the order, would be the consequences in case of a failure on the part of the plaintiff to comply with these conditions? The answer must be, that he would forfeit his right to amend. Now, the plaintiff having failed to comply with these conditions, lost the benefit of the order of court allowing him to amend his affidavit in replevin. The result was, that the pleadings in the case were left in precisely the same condition that they were before the leave to amend was granted.
For reasons heretofore given this case is reversed and remanded to the district court, with orders that the case be reinstated, and for such action as will carry out the idea expressed in this opinion.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Florence Bayless v. Robert McFarland
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Replevin — Affidavit in Amendmenls — Dismissal. Where, after the granting of a new trial, a party asks leave of court to amend the affidavit in replevin, and leave is granted by the court on condition that (1) the same be made within ten days, and (2) that the plaintiff pay all costs in this action to this date within ten days, the conditions only apply to the right to amend, and if the party fails to comply with the conditions, he only forfeits his right to amend, and in such event the pleadings in the case remain precisely in the same condition they were before the leave to amend was granted; and if such pleadings properly present a case, the court should hear and det ermine the same on the merits; and it is error for the court to make an order dismissing the» case for a failure to comply with the conditions attached to the leave to amend. (Syllabus by the Court.)