Cable v. Myers

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Cable v. Myers, 142 P. 1114 (Okla. 1914)
43 Okla. 302; 1914 OK 400; 1914 Okla. LEXIS 517
Bleakmore

Cable v. Myers

Opinion of the Court

BLEAKMORE, J.

This case presents error from the superior court of Pottawatomie county, and is an appeal from a final order of that court upon the motion of plaintiff in error to retax costs. Attached to the petition in error is a purported transcript of the record. There is neither case-made nor bill of exceptions; and, for these reasons, defendant in error has filed his motion to dismiss this proceeding.

This court has repeatedly held that the rulings of a trial court upon motion cannot be reviewed here, unless such matters are made a part of the record by bill of exceptions or case-made. In Bruner et al. v. Kansas Moline Plow Co., 24 Okla. 158, 103 Pac. 673, it was held:

“The only way that this court may re-examine the taxing of costs in the trial court is on appeal, by means of a bill of exceptions or case-made.”

It follows that the motion to dismiss this case should be sustained; and it is so ordered.

All the Justices concur.

Reference

Cited By
7 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
APPEAL AND ERROR, — Presentation for Review. Rulings of a trial court upon motion cannot be reviewed by this court, unless made a part of the record by bill of exceptions or case-made. (Syllabus by the Court.)