State v. Hynes

Court of Appeals of Oregon
State v. Hynes, 27 Or. App. 37 (1976)
554 P.2d 1030; 1976 Ore. App. LEXIS 1298
Schwab, Sloan, Tanzer

State v. Hynes

Opinion of the Court

SLOAN, S. J.

The court below, in this mental commitment hearing, took judicial notice of the record of a prior commitment proceeding concerning David Hynes. State v. O’Neill, 274 Or 59, 545 P2d 97 (1976), held that judicial notice of prior court files was improper. The state, however, argues that O’Neill is inapplicable where the judicial notice is taken in the dispositional "phase” of a commitment hearing rather than in the adjudicative phase of the hearing. We must disagree. Whether or not ORS ch 426 now provides for a separate dispositional "phase” of the commitment process, we read State v. O’Neill, supra, as precluding taking judicial notice of prior court files in any event.

Reversed and remanded.

Reference

Full Case Name
In the Matter of David A. Hynes, Alleged to be a Mentally Ill Person. STATE OF OREGON v. DAVID A. HYNES
Cited By
2 cases
Status
Published