Court of Appeals of Oregon, 1978

Ripnitz v. Jones

Ripnitz v. Jones
Court of Appeals of Oregon · Decided September 18, 1978 · Gillette, Roberts, Schwab
36 Or. App. 183; 584 P.2d 315; 1978 Ore. App. LEXIS 1828

Ripnitz v. Jones

Opinion of the Court

SCHWAB, C. J.

In this equity proceeding defendant appeals from a decree dismissing plaintiffs suit contending the court had no power to order dismissal "without prejudice.” At trial plaintiffs presented their case-in-chief and rested. The defendants rested without introducing any testimony and moved for a decree of dismissal on the ground that plaintiffs had failed to prove they were entitled to any relief. The court found that the motion was well taken and that it should be allowed.

The dismissal of a suit on motion of a defendant after plaintiff has rested constitutes a bar to any subsequent suit for the same cause. ORS 18.220; Kelley et ux. v. Mallory et ux., 202 Or 690, 277 P2d 767 (1954).

Reversed and remanded for entry of a decree dismissing with prejudice.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.