McCormick v. State
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- McCormick v. State Parks and Recreation Dept. (Or. 2020)
- McCormick v. State Parks and Recreation Dept. (Or. Ct. App. 2020)
- Ortega v. Martin (Or. Ct. App. 2021)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
*200*199Plaintiff was severely injured when, while visiting Cove Palisades State Park, he dove into Lake Billy Chinook and hit his head on a submerged boulder. He sued the state, alleging that the state's negligence causally contributed to his injuries in a number of ways. The state moved for summary judgment, contending that ORS 105.682, the recreational immunity statute, barred plaintiff's claims against it because plaintiff was engaged in a recreational activity at the time of his injuries. Plaintiff opposed the motion, arguing, among other things, that the statute did not apply to Lake Billy Chinook because the state holds Lake Billy Chinook in trust for the public and, as a result, lacks the authority to prohibit the public from using Lake Billy Chinook for recreational purposes. The trial court agreed with the state that it was entitled to recreational immunity under ORS 105.682, granted the motion for summary judgment, and entered a general judgment dismissing the complaint. We reverse, concluding that the trial court's ruling was erroneous in view of our decision today in Ortega v. Martin ,
Under ORS 105.682, a landowner is entitled to recreational immunity from liability for harm resulting from the recreational use of the owner's land when, among other criteria, the owner "directly or indirectly permits any person to use the land for recreational purposes." ORS 105.682(1) (emphasis added). In this case, the question is whether the state "permits" the recreational use of Lake Billy Chinook within the meaning of the statute. Plaintiff argues that, to "permit" recreational use within the meaning of the statute, the state must have the authority to decide whether or not to allow recreational use; that is, it must have the authority to prohibit recreational use. The state, although generally not disputing that it lacks the authority to completely bar the public from the recreational use of Lake Billy Chinook,
Although both readings of the statute are plausible, under our decision in Ortega , plaintiff's interpretation is correct. There, after reviewing the text, context, and legislative history of ORS 105.682 in light of arguments virtually identical to those raised in this appeal, we concluded that, to "permit" recreational use within the meaning of the statute, "an owner must have the authority to make a volitional decision whether or not to allow recreational use on the land in question." Ortega ,
Here, the state has not effectively demonstrated
Reversed and remanded.
Following our decision in Landis v. Limbaugh ,
As noted, the state belatedly contended that it has the authority to prohibit the public's recreational use of Lake Billy Chinook but we have declined to consider that argument.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.