District Court, D. Oregon, 2021

Hsieh v. Multnomah County Department of Community Services

Hsieh v. Multnomah County Department of Community Services
District Court, D. Oregon · Decided October 19, 2021 · No. 3:20-cv-01758
Hsieh v. Multnomah County Department of Community Services

Trial Court Opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF OREGON

PORTLAND DIVISION

MARLENE MANLING HSIEH,

Plaintiff,

Case No. 3:20-cv-01758-MO v.

MULTNOMAH COUNTY OPINION AND ORDER DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY

SERVICES, MULTNOMAH COUNTY

ANIMAL SERVICES, CHRISTIAN

HOLDEN, Animal Control Officer IT

Multnomah County Animal Services,

JEANETTE FARRELL, Field Service

Supervisor Multnomah County Animal

Services, JACKIE ROSE, Director of

Multnomah County Animal Services at the time, KIM PEOPLES, Director of

Multnomah County Department of Community

Services at the time,

Defendants.

MOSMAN, J.,

On January 5, 2021 this Court, applying the doctrine of Younger abstention, STAYED Marlene Mangling Hsieh’s 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action for monetary damages pending resolution of her appeal for her conviction for animal abuse before the Oregon Court of Appeals. [ECF 18]. On September 9, 2021 the Court of Appeals issued its opinion affirming the trial court’s decision. [ECF 28] Ex. 1. The Court of Appeals found no violation of Ms. Hseih’s Fourth Amendment rights because the exigent circumstances exception to the Fourth Amendment applied. [ECF 28] Ex. 1 at 16-17. Now that the state court has ruled, a stay is no longer proper under Younger abstention. See Arevalo v. Hennessy, 882 F.3d 763, 765 (9th Cir. 2018) (internal citations omitted). Because the Court of Appeals found that Ms. Hsieh’s Fourth Amendment rights were not violated, she no longer has a claim for $8.8 million in damages under § 1983. Therefore, I DISMISS the complaint with prejudice. ae

DATED this day of October, 2021.

MICHAEL W. MOS

United States Districtsudge

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.