Lutton's Estate

Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Lutton's Estate, 17 Pa. Super. 342 (1901)
1901 Pa. Super. LEXIS 316
Beaver, Oblady, Orlady, Pobteb, Rice

Lutton's Estate

Opinion of the Court

Opinion by

Orlady, J.,

On December 30, 1899, Benjamin Lutton filed a petition in the orphans’ court to set aside a confirmation absolute of an auditor’s report which made a distribution of the proceeds of a sale of real estate that had been sold by the administratrix of Joseph Lutton, under an order of the orphans’ court for the payment of debts of the decedent. A rule to show cause was granted and after a hearing it was discharged. The item allowed by the auditor in regard to which this controversy arises was a judgment obtained against the administratrix for a tombstone ordered by her.

It has been repeatedly held that an allowance for such an expenditure is entirely proper and that credit for it should be given against the estate of the decedent: Webb’s Estate, 165 Pa. 330. The fact that the petitioner was a minor at the time the judgment was obtained and when the order of sale was made did not in any manner contribute to its allowance. The reasonableness of the cost of the tombstone was determined by the auditor and the auditing judge after a full hearing. The administratrix did not pay and the judgment was obtained against her only after she had actively resisted the claim. Neither the appellant nor his guardian could have changed :the result had either been present, as the counsel of appellant is the same as at that time represented the administratrix.

This was not a debt of the decedent, but, as had been adjudged by the orphans’ court, was a reasonable expense incurred in the settlement of his estate.

The decree is affirmed.

Reference

Cited By
4 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
Decedents' estates — Gost of tombstone — Executors and administrators. A reasonable sum for the cost of a tombstone for a decedent should be allowed out of the decedent’s estate. Where a judgment has been recovered against an administratrix for the cost of a tombstone for the decedent, and an auditor has allowed such, judgment out of the proceeds of real estate sold for the payment of debts, and his report has been confirmed by the court, the confirmation of the report will not be set aside because one of the distributees of the estate was a minor at the time the judgment .was obtained and when the order of sale was made.