Christy's Estate
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Commonwealth v. Lennon (Pa. Super. Ct. 1936)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This appeal is from a decree of the court below making distribution of a fund consisting of the royalties accruing under certain leases for mining coal upon lands in Cambria county, of which John T. Christy died seized. The question we have to decide is one of title to the land, the nature of the estate which Francis M. Christy acquired under the will of his father, the testator. The testator, by his will, first made provision for his wife, Mary A. J. Christy, by devising to her certain property in fee, and then devised to her a life estate in the residue of his property, which included the tract in question, by a clause in the words following, viz.: “And the one-third of all the rents and income of my estate, as long as she remains my widow. . . . If Francis, my son, should die before marriage his mother shall be his heir during her widowhood.” The testator then proceeded to make provision for Francis, his only son, by devising to him certain real estate in fee to be presently enjoyed, and following these devises come the clauses of the will which are material to the consideration of this case, being the only clauses of the will making disposition of the Cambria county lands after the death or remarriage of Mary A. J. Christy, the widow. This devise was in the following words: “ He shall have the two-thirds of all my lands in Gallitzin Township, Cambria Co., the income of rent liens during his mother’s widowhood. After he shall have all the proceeds during his lifetime. After his death it shall go to his heirs free and unencumbered by any debts of his except for developing mines &c.—If my son Francis should die without heirs I leave my sister Sarah Inlow the one-fourth of my estate (her husband nothing). The other three-fourths to my broth
Francis M. Christy having not only married but outlived the widow of the testator, the contingency upon which the widow was to take, during her widowhood, the share of the estate devised to Francis never happened; that devise fell. We have, therefore, only to consider the clauses of the will disposing of the remainder after the termination of the particular-estate which the testator created in order to make provision for his widow during her widowhood. There can be no doubt, under the provisions of the will, that the intention of the testator was that the land should go, after the death of the widow, to Francis during his lifetime, and that the remainder, after the life estate of Francis, should “go to his heirs free and unencumbered by any debts of his except for developing mines.” The devise over, “If my son Francis should die without heirs,” is to the sister and brothers of the testator and their heirs. This language clearly implies that he did not intend his sister and brothers, or their
The decree of the court below is affirmed and the appeal dismissed at cost of the appellants.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.