Thomas v. Dickerson
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Adams ex rel. Drake v. Adams (Montour County Court of Common Pleas 1925)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The plaintiff having furnished sand to the firm of Bunyea & Dickerson brought suit before a justice of the peace for the amount of his claim and obtained judgment therefor. Edward Dickerson, one of the partners, appealed the case to the court of common pleas and filed an affidavit of defense therein in which he suggested the death of Bunyea, one of the partners, and set forth the defense which he proposed to make on the merits of the case. The transcript of the justice filed in the court below is not printed by the appellant. It is stated in the history of the case, however, that the record showed a service on both partners, and it is admitted that service was made on Dickerson, the appellant. After the filing of the affidavit of defense the plaintiff obtained a rule to show cause why the record should not be amended by substituting for the name of the defendant wherever the same appeared on the record and particularly in the appeal, statement of claim and all other papers filed in the case the following: “Edward Dickerson, liquidating and surviving partner of Martin Bunyea, which said Martin Bunyea in his
The remaining question is, was the affidavit of defense sufficient? We agree with the learned judge of the court below that it does not set forth any facts which contradict the right of the plaintiff to recover. There is no denial that the sand was received by the firm nor assertion that the price was more than the plaintiff was entitled to have. The allegation of payment is insufficient under all the authorities. No information is given as to the time of payment, by whom made, or the manner or amount of such payments. There is no averment that the plaintiff refused permission to the defendant to examine the plaintiff’s books or that he ever made any effort to look at them, and if he needed time for that purpose he should have asked for an extension of time to permit him so to do. The appellant’s lack of familiarity with this branch of the business of the firm does not relieve him from the necessity of filing an affidavit which sets up a defense. The record shows that he had more than two months from the time the action was brought until the date of the filing of the affidavit of defense in which to inquire in regard to the correctness of the plaintiff’s demand, and his written ad
The assignments are overruled and the judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.