Schenk v. Fetzer
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
Unless the defendants were entitled to a directed verdict in their favor the first and third assignments of error cannot be sustained. Under the evidence no such direction could have properly been given on the ground that no recovery could be had against Frank Fetzer, who, with his brother, was alleged to have constituted the partnership trading under the name of Fetzer Bros. Company. There was a general appearance for both. The only affidavit of defense was made by William H. Fetzer. A single plea of the general issue was entered for both. The testimony, including the correspondence that passed between the parties, tended to prove that the plaintiff was dealing with a partnership. Frank Fetzer neither filed an affidavit in his own behalf nor was he called as a witness. His brother testified: “We did business as Fetzer Brothers Company. He is now associated with me in business. At that time he was employed, but we contemplated becoming partners and adopted that firm name. ’ ’ Whilst the witness testified that at the time this particular contract was made his brother was not then a member of the firm, he further said: “He had authority though to sign any contract.” He was then asked, “You were contemplating the formation of a partnership, and in contemplation of that you were doing business as Fetzer Brothers Company? A. Fetzer Brothers Company, so stated on our reports to the Mercantile Companies and Banks.” There was ample warrant under this state of facts for the jury to find that Frank Fetzer was being held out to the world as a member of the firm,- and there is no denial by him that this was with his knowledge and assent. It was not possible therefore for the trial court to declare as matter of law, that the plaintiff could not recover against the partnership, and no directed verdict on this ground could be justified.
It is admitted in the affidavit of defense that a concrete mixer was purchased from the plaintiff upon the following condition: “He (affiant) was to have the use of said mixer for a period of two weeks at a cost of $2.00 per day, and
The second and only remaining assignment complains of the charge of the court. It is not apparent that this complaint rests on any other ground than that the court submitted a question of fact to the jury. The manner of the submission we do not understand to be challenged. The learned judge said: “The evidence shows that the machine, after it had been received, did perform its work for two or three days at least, and when the plaintiff was informed that the machine was not working properly, he went on the premises, examined the machine and found that the difficulty arose from two causes. One was that the machine had not been properly cleaned, allowing
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.