Wilson v. Eckman
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Smith's Estate (Philadelphia County Orphans' Court 1941)
- Coleman & Stahl v. Weimer (Pa. Super. Ct. 1925)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This is a scire facias upon a mortgage, dated December 17, 1885, and recorded the same day, and which became due and payable one day after the date thereof. Phoebe Mills, the mortgagor, died April 21, 1910. The writ of scire facias issued on March 3, 1911. The debt secured by the mortgage, it thus appears, had been due and payable for a period of more than twenty-five years before this proceeding was instituted for its collection. The plaintiff recovered a verdict and judgment in the court below and the defendants appeal. The appellants state the question involved to be: “In a suit on a mortgage due by its terms more than twenty-five years be
The presumption that all debts excepted out of the statute of limitations, unclaimed and unrecognized for twenty years, are paid, is an artificial rule of law and, unlike the statute of limitations, is not a bar to an action on the original contract, and therefore a new promise is not necessary to sustain the suit. Any competent evidence which tends to show that the debt is in fact unpaid is admissible for the purpose of rebutting the presumption of payment. The question, as against the presumption, is whether or not the debt is in fact unpaid. The presumption of payment after twenty years is a strong one, and the evidence to rebut it must be satisfactory and convincing; it must carry conviction to the mind of the court, that if the facts alleged are true, the matters in issue are definitely and distinctly established. It is of no consequence that the admission of nonpayment is accompanied by a refusal to pay, or a declaration of an intention not to do so. The evidence may consist of the debtor’s admissions made to the creditor himself; or to his agent or to a stranger: Morrison v. Funk, 23 Pa. 421; Reed v. Reed, 46 Pa. 239. An admission that the debt is unpaid will not be as readily implied from vague and equivocal language casually addressed to a stranger, as when addressed to the creditor in reply to a demand for the debt: Bentley’s App., 99 Pa. 500; Gregory v. Com., 121 Pa. 611; Porter v. Nelson, 121 Pa. 628; Fidelity Title & Trust Co. v. Chapman, 226 Pa. 312. Whether the facts relied upon by the creditor, if established, are sufficient to rebut the presumption is a question for the court, but whether the testimony relied upon to establish those facts is true is a question of fact for the jury: Delany v. Robinson, 2 Wharton, 503; Reed v. Reed, 46 Pa. 439.
The judgment is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.