Rochester Building & Loan Ass'n v. Beaver Valley Water Co.
Rochester Building & Loan Ass'n v. Beaver Valley Water Co.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This is an appeal from the order of the court below directing a mandatory preliminary injunction to issue requiring the appellant to renew its water service to the property purchased by the appellee at sheriff’s sale. This service was discontinued, upon the former owner’s default in paying the water rent, before the property was sold by the sheriff. The appellee tendered the service connection charge of $ 1, and offered to enter into a contract, in the usual form, with the appellant, but these offers were refused, because the appellee declined to pay the delinquent water rent. The demand for payment of delinquent rent was made pursuant to a rule or regulation of the company. A petition was then filed by the appellee with the Public Service Commission asking that the appellant be compelled to reestablish this service. Before the case was disposed of by the commission, or within a week after it was presented, this bill was filed.
The appellant urges that the jurisdiction heretofore conferred on the several courts, to determine the matters raised by this bill, was placed within the exclusive control of the Public Service Commission by the Act of July 26, 1913, P, L. 1374, known as the Public Service Act. This act, in so far as it attempts to regulate and control public service companies, places the determination of all such matters exclusively in this commission; but the jurisdiction of the several courts of this Commonwealth is not supplanted where the Public Service Act does not give relief or supply a remedy to secure a right infringed upon. Section 6 of Article YI provides that “any person ......complaining of anything done or about to be done, omitted or about to be omitted, by any public service company, in violation of any of the requirements or provisions of this act, or of any lawful determination, ruling, or order of the commission, may apply to the commission by petition, duly verified by the affidavit of the complainant, which shall contain a concise statement of all the material facts upon which the complaint is founded.” Under this section a party aggrieved may place his complaint before the commission. In our case the complaint was as to the unreasonableness of a rule or regulation. Section 1, Article II, (d), requires all rules and regulations that in any manner affect the prices, charges, rates, fares, toll?, or other compensation,
The decree of the court below is reversed, and it is Ordered that the mandatory preliminary injunction here
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Rochester Building & Loan Assn. v. Beaver Valley Water Co.
- Cited By
- 13 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Corporations — Water companies — Rules and regulations — Cutting off service — Notice—Subsequent purchaser — Mandatory preliminary injunction — Public Service Commission — Equity. A purchaser at a sheriff's sale of property from which the water service had been cut off by the water company upon the former owner’s default in paying the water rent, is not entitled to a mandatory preliminary injunction to compel a renewal of the water service, where it appears that the cutting off of the service was in pursuance of a rule or regulation of the company, and that the rules and regulations of the “company had been posted in compliance with the Public Service Act. A municipality or a corporation furnishing water or gas may by ordinance or by-laws make reasonable rules and regulations to assure the payment of bills, among others, that of stopping the supply unless all arrearages are paid, whether owing by the tenant in possession or his predecessors; but they cannot refuse to supply water because of a former owner’s delinquent water rent, unless it appears that the resident had notice that he would be required to pay such bill. The reasonableness of a rule or regulation of a water company requiring a purchaser of a property to pay a former owner’s delinquent water rent before water service is renewed, is a matter purely for the Public Service Commission.