Com. v. Smalls, J.
Opinion
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P. 65.37 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
Appellant v.
JURELL SMALLS
Appellee No. 1723 EDA 2014 Appeal from the Order May 13, 2014
In the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County Criminal Division at No(s): CP-46-CR-0008154-2012
CP-46-CR-0008377-2012 BEFORE: DONOHUE, J., MUNDY, J., and FITZGERALD, J.* DISSENTING MEMORANDUM BY MUNDY, J.: FILED DECEMBER 29, 2015
I respectfully dissent. Even if I agreed with the Majority’s conclusion that the evidence of Appellee’s personal drug trafficking of prescription pills was stale,1 I do not agree that this renders the warrant wholly invalid. Accordingly, I disagree that all of the evidence seized in the execution of the search warrant for the residence located at 116 East Third Street, Lansdale, Pennsylvania must be suppressed. Therefore, I would reverse the trial court’s order granting Appellee’s motion to suppress the evidence.
I agree with the Majority’s suggestion that the police presented probable cause to search the residence for marijuana. See Majority Memorandum at 15 (recognizing “probable cause likely existed for a search of marijuana…[]”). Specifically, I would conclude there was probable cause of cultivating, harvesting, and processing marijuana plants along with evidence of marijuana possession and use.2 Because there was probable cause to search for and seize marijuana, I would sever the authorization to search for any items for which probable cause did not exist, including prescription pills, from the warrant. Further, I would conclude that in the lawful search for marijuana, the plain view doctrine applies and, additionally, that the police would have inevitably discovered evidence of prescription pills. Accordingly, I would conclude that the evidence obtained through the warrant should not have been suppressed.
This Court has explained that when probable cause supports certain items in a search warrant but not others, the items that are not supported by probable cause may be severed from the warrant.
The doctrine of severance mandates that invalid portions of a search warrant may be stricken and the remaining portions held valid, as long as the remaining portions of the warrant describe with particularity the evidence to be seized. Where a search warrant authorizes seizure of some items for which there is probable cause and other items for which there is no probable cause, the warrant is not wholly invalid. In such cases, suppression will be required only of the evidence which was seized without probable cause.
Commonwealth v. Anderson, 40 A.3d 1245 (Pa. Super. 2012), appeal denied, 51 A.3d 837, quoting Commonwealth v. Bagley, 596 A.2d 811, 824 (Pa. Super. 1991), appeal denied, 611 A.2d 710 (Pa. 1992), cert. denied, Bagley v. Pennsylvania, 506 U.S. 1002 (1992).
In Anderson, police obtained a search warrant for the appellant’s apartment based on probable cause for marijuana. Anderson, supra at 1245. However, the search warrant also contained authorization to search for and seize cocaine, heroin, and any other controlled substances, for which there was no probable cause. Id. In executing the warrant, the police seized marijuana, cocaine, and drug paraphernalia. Id. Because there was no probable cause to support the issuance of a warrant for any drug other than marijuana, the suppression court severed the portions of the search warrant that referred to other controlled substances and suppressed all of the evidence that was not related to marijuana. Id. This Court reversed the suppression court, concluding that the evidence of cocaine and drug paraphernalia, for which there was no probable cause in the search warrant, should not have been suppressed. We explained that the entire warrant was not invalid because there was probable cause to search the apartment for marijuana. Id. at 1249. Instead, we concluded that any evidence discovered in plain view during the lawful search for marijuana was admissible and, further, that evidence of the other contraband would have been inevitably discovered during the lawful search for marijuana. Id.
Applying Anderson to this case, I would conclude that if the evidence of prescription pill trafficking was stale, it should have been severed from the warrant. This does not, however, render the entire search warrant invalid because there was still probable cause to search for marijuana. Specifically, the search warrant authorized the search for, and seizure of, the following marijuana-related items, among others.
1. Marijuana, Prescription Pills and any other controlled substances; 2. Cutting agents, bagging materials, scales, other drug paraphernalia; 3. Items used to grow Marijuana indoors/outdoors,
Marijuana seeds, PVC piping, grow lights, ballasts, circulating[] fans, exhaust fans, light canopies, electrical timers, light rails, circular light movers, hydroponic containers, grow mediums, CO2 injection systems, fertilizers, potting soil, containers for planting, chemicals and fertilizers, pruning and gardening tools, buyers lists, seller lists and other miscellaneous items used to grow Marijuana.
4. Marijuana or any parts thereof (such as living plants and dried processed matter) and paraphernalia commonly associated with the cultivation, storage and sales and use of Marijuana (such as baggies, scales, drying items and other weighing devices), lights, hoses, and other paraphernalia used for growing marijuana, books and pamphlets containing instructions on cultivation, paper[] recording devices, pay-owe sheets, buyers lists, ledgers, and other items that can be used to record sale transactions.
… Application for Search Warrant and Authorization, 9/21/12, at Exhibit A, Property to be Searched for and Seized, at ¶¶ 1-4.
Accordingly, the police in executing the warrant could lawfully search any area of the residence where the above evidence of marijuana possession, consumption, and cultivation could have been located.3 Therefore, the evidence of possession of marijuana and of drug paraphernalia to use marijuana was lawfully obtained through a search warrant supported by probable cause and should not be suppressed.4 Further, even if I severed as stale the authorization to search for prescription pills from the search warrant, I would conclude that in searching for marijuana, the police would have discovered the prescription pills in plain view. See Anderson, supra. Alternatively, I would conclude the prescription pills would have been inevitably discovered. See id. Therefore, I would reverse the trial court’s order granting suppression and remand for a trial. I respectfully dissent.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.