Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, 1785

Liber v. Executors of Parsons

Liber v. Executors of Parsons
Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas · Decided January 15, 1785 · Pendleton
1 S.C.L. 19

Counsel

Pinckney, for defendants,, Bay, contra.

Liber v. Executors of Parsons

Opinion of the Court

Pendleton, J.

There can be no doubt but that the-measure of estimating damages, in a case like the present, is the value of the land at the time of the eviction. Men do not make purchases, with a view of merely having interest for their money ; but they contemplate the rise in the value of the thing purchased. That value, then, the plaintiffs are justly entitled to. It is true, the whole lot is not recovered from them : a part still remains ; but the remaining part is greatly depreciated by the shape of it. It is, therefore, a matter altogether for the consideration of the jury, in the estimate of damages they mean to give, whether they will apportion the damages according' to the amount of the injury sustained, or give the full amount of the value of the lot, so as to rescind the contract, entirely, as they think proper.

Verdict for plaintiffs to the full value of the lot — 238/. 13.?. 6(f,

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.