Stiles v. The John Stevens
Stiles v. The John Stevens
Opinion of the Court
The steamer John Stevens approached her landing place on the Delaware obliquely from the channel, at night, and against the tide, with her steam shut off, and her headway nearly arrested, when within a distance considerably less than her length from the head of the wharf at which she was to come to she encountered a small vessel, which had temporarily taken a position near the. wharf immediately above, while waiting for a change of tide to drop down to her berth. The boom of the sloop struck the wheelliouse of the steamer, passed through the side of the cabin, and damaged it considerably. In return the boom was broken by the collision, and the sloop received other injuries. The owner of the sloop files his libel, and asks damages against the steamer. The sloop was not at the wharf, and she had no signal lamp hoisted. This is admitted on all hands, though the witnesses, in speaking of her distance from the
Now, without deciding whether a vessel is to be regarded as at anchor in the stream so as to be bound to show a light, when, although in the tide way and at anchor, she is within mooring distance of a wharf, and attached to it by appropriate fasts, we have no hesitation in saying that a vessel so placing herself, not in absolute contact with the wharf, or with the vessels at the wharf, but at some distance from it or them, must take the consequences of a collision, if she allows her boom at night so to project over her side as to infringe against a vessel which is moving prudently to her accustomed berth.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STILES v. The JOHN STEVENS
- Status
- Published