Winton Motor Carriage Co. v. Curtis Pub. Co.
Winton Motor Carriage Co. v. Curtis Pub. Co.
Opinion of the Court
It is no doubt true that under exceptional circumstances a court of equity will issue a mandatory injunction even at a preliminary stage in the litigation. But heretofore — so far as appears from the cases cited — the writ has been issued for the sole purpose of preserving or of restoring a status in order that a dispute might be fully heard and the rights of the parties determined upon final hearing. Here there is no status to be preserved or restored — the contract in question being still executory — and therefore the pending motion asks the court to take a long step in advance; for a preliminary injunction is now requested that shall decide .the whole of a controversy at the very beginning of a suit, and shall enforce specifically a contract whose terms and scope are still undetermined. Concededly an agreement of some kind was made, but its precise terms and scope aré the subject of dispute. A brief statement of the facts will make the situation more clear.
The defendant publishes the Saturday Evening Post in the city of Philadelphia. This is a weekly journal of very large circulation, and, by reason of the social and financial standing of many of its readers, it is an unusually valuable medium for advertisements of automobiles. About a year ago the defendant agreed with the plaintiff, a manufacturer of high standing, to publish such an advertisement- in the issue of June 29, 1912. When the contract was made, neither party knew what the contents of the advertisement would be. In May, 1912, the copy was submitted to the defendant, and was rejected, after conference and consideration, on the ground that it. contained misleading statements and reflected injuriously upon competing manufacturers. Eor this reason the defendant regarded it as obnoxious to one of the journal’s rules, which is averred to have been well known to the plaintiff. Thereupon the. pending bill was filed,
The motion is refused.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- WINTON MOTOR CARRIAGE CO. v. CURTIS PUB. CO.
- Status
- Published