In re Dissolution of Fraternal Order of Firemen
Opinion of the Court
— On May 29, 1947, a petition was presented to the court for the dissolution of Fraternal Order of Firemen, Lancaster, Pa., a nonprofit corporation. On the return day of the
Under the bylaws of the Fraternal Order of Firemen, Lancaster, Pa., effective January 8, 1945, section 40 (A), it is provided as to qualifications for membership : “He shall also be a member of the Lancaster Fire Department or any paid Fire Department.” In Gordon et al. v. Tomei et al., 144 Pa. Superior Ct. 449, 457 (1941), it was held that the bylaws of a corporation are “its private statutes for its own government, unless contrary to the laws of the land.” The bylaws “regulate its own action and concerns, and the rights and duties of its members amongst themselves.” Petitioner contends that there must be a provision in the charter of a nonprofit corporation if continuing membership in
“Membership in a nonprofit corporation shall be terminated in the manner provided in the articles or by-laws. If the membership in any such corporation is limited to persons who are members in good standing in another corporation, or in any lodge, church, club or society, the articles shall in each case define such limitations, and may provide that failure on the part of any such member to keep himself in good standing in such other corporation or association shall be sufficient cause for expelling the member from the corporation requiring such eligibility.”
The court is of the opinion that the last cited act is not applicable to the instant case because William Ansel was not a member in another corporation or association, but an employe under civil service in the Lancaster Fire Department. Accordingly, petitioner, William Ansel, became ineligible for membership in the Fraternal Order of Firemen, Lancaster, Pa., when he voluntarily resigned from the Lancaster Fire Department on September 1, 1945. The question of his status should have been raised after the order of dissolution because he is not opposed to the dissolution, but is asking to participate in the distribution of the assets. However, the court finds that he is not entitled to participate in the distribution of the assets and property of the Fraternal Order of Firemen, Lancaster, Pa.
And now, August 1, 1947, the rule to show cause why William Ansel should not participate as a member in the distribution of the assets and property of the Fraternal Order of Firemen, Lancaster, Pa., is discharged.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.