Payne's Estate
Opinion of the Court
This is a petition under section 6 of the Fiduciaries Act (Act of June 7, 1917, P. L. 447) and prays for a declaration that a certain person is presumed to be dead, as of a certain date, and that, therefore, real estate which he held as tenant by entireties with his wife has become her property, and by her subsequent death has passed to her heirs, who are the petitioners. It has been referred to a master, who has reported facts and a decree fully complying with the prayer. Heirs of the presumed decedent contested the matter before the master and have presented exceptions attacking not only the finding of death and the date but also the propriety of any conclusion as to the effect of the death, and further questioning the standing of the petitioners.
A petitioner who claims not under the presumed decedent but against him has no standing. A proceeding seeking a decree — not that by reason of a man’s death his property has passed to his heirs, but that by reason of his death he has no property which can pass to his heirs — has neither subject-matter nor parties, and we have no jurisdiction of it. The mistake of the petitioners seems to lie in supposing that, however the question arises, it is necessary first to establish the presumption of death in this court. It is not a doctrine peculiar to this court; we apply it for our own purposes, and so do other courts.
The exceptions are sustained and the petition is dismissed; the costs, including master’s fee, $200, and the bill of Henry B. Tawresey, stenographer, $71.50, to be paid one-half by the petitioners and one-half by the exceptants.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.