Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1776

Steiner v. Fell

Steiner v. Fell
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided April 15, 1776
1 Dall. 22; 1 U.S. 22

Steiner v. Fell

Opinion of the Court

By the Court.

Whenever a writ issues fairly, if it is first delivered it shall take preference—The proceedings, on a Habeas Corpus are de novo; on a certiorari, the court proceed on the state returned. Therefore, both writs cannot issue in the same cause; for the court cannot proceed de novo and on the old record too; which upon the idea of returning both writs must be done. In this case, the defendant not having affected delay, but proceeded in the *23usual course, having taken out the first writ, and delivered it as soon as was usual, his writ should take preference; and the Court accordingly order the return to be made on the Habeas Corpus.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.