Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1793

Shoemaker v. Keeley

Shoemaker v. Keeley
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided April 15, 1793
1 Yeates 245

Shoemaker v. Keeley

Opinion of the Court

Per Cur.

The form of the action is decisive. The damages here are as uncertain as in any species of trespass, and cannot be assigned over by the commissioners. Matters of ■ mere tort were not contemplated by the legislature when they enacted the bankrupt law. The assignees might, if they had thought proper, have brought assumpsit, and then the defendant would have had the benefit of a set-off; but, the suit in its present form, cannot be supported.

Judgment for the defendant.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.