Peaceable v. Nicholls
Peaceable v. Nicholls
Opinion of the Court
Ejectment for 400 acres of land in Mount Pleasant township. The lessor of the plaintiff grounded his pretensions to the lands in controversy, on an application entered in the land office 3d April 176.9, No. 554, for 300 acres of land, adjoining a small branch of Sewickley, on Braddock’s road, the south side of Jacob’s swamp.
Isaac Meason, esq. proved,that one George Paul the brother in law of Irwin, called on him between the years 1774 and 1776, as deputy of William Thompson, esq. surveyor of the district, to make a survey thereon of the lands then in the occupation of Nicholls, one of the defendants: that he went on the ground, and it appearing that the location was more descriptive of other lands, particularly a place now held by Benjamin Lodge, he mentioned that circumstance to Paul, and they at length declined making the survey, Paul saying, he would write to Irwin on the subject, who should judge for himself: that no force or threats were made use of by the then holders of the lands, to prevent a survey, and that no further application was ever made to him to make the survey.
Benjamin Lodge swore, that the location might be supposed to describe with convenient certainty the lands in the possession of Nicholls, but not exclusively of other tracts.
On the part of the defendants it appeared, that George Swan held part of the lands in dispute, under a permission from captain Charles Edmonstone, commanding officer to the westward, dated 33d October 1768, to Prior Theobold, to take up a place on Jacob’s swamp, on Braddock’s road, a location dated 9th August 1769, No. 3723, for 300 acres of land on the waters of Jacob’s creek and Sewickley, reciting Edmon-stone’s permission together with his improvement, and an ancient settlement of Theobold his predecessor: and that John Nicholls in 1770, had seated himself on part of these lands and cultivated them, and afterwards purchased in an application of Hercules Druuffield, dated 13th June 1769, No. 3134, for 300 acres of land adjoining Thomas Thorñpson on the east side, and on both sides of Braddock’s road, upon which no survey had been made or applied for.
After argument by Mr. Woods for the plaintiff, and Mr. J. Ross for the defendants, Yeates J. remarked in his charge to * the jury, that the plaintiff must recover by his own r^ooA strength, and not by the weakness of his adversaries. ^
Plaintiff nonsuit.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Peter Peaceable lessee of Archibald Irwin, against John Nicholls and George Swan
- Status
- Published