Rapelje v. Emery
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- (PC) Sharonoff v. Lizarraga (United States District Court for the Eastern District of California 2019)
- (PC) Brown v. Castrillo (United States District Court for the Eastern District of California 2019)
- Woolslayer Companies, Inc. v. Woolslayer (United States District Court, Oklahoma Northern 2019)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
—Upon every view of the subject, I am of opinion, that a new trial ought to be granted. The proceedings of the Court of St. Eustatius we must presume to be conformable to the law of the place; the decision appears to be strictly just; and, independent of the merits, we are bound by it, as the decision of a competent tribunal.
Having delivered my sentiments at large, in this action, from, another Bench, I mean now only to take notice of two new cases, cited at the last argument by the plaintiff’s counsel, to shew that actions for money had and received, had been brought and supported against plaintiffs, who had recovered 'upon foreign attachments, to oblige them to refund to third persons, the money so recovered. These are the cases of
This principle fully reaches the cafe before us. Emery, a creditor of Fairchild, attaches his efrefts in a foreign Country, in the hands of Smith, the agent of Fairchild; Smith appears and makes defence, and, no doubt, communicated to the Court the circumstances, which, lay the foundation of the present plaintiff'claim. The Court adjudged, that the money in the hands of Smith, was the property of Fairchild, and compel him by their judgment to pay Emery his debt out of it. Now if, we should even be of opinion, that the money in the hands of Smith was the property of Rapalje, and not of Fairchild, yet, upon the principle of the case determined by Lord Fougborough, we have no power to
' Yeates, Justice. Whatever irregularity there may have been in rendering the foreign judgment, the judgment itself is conclusive, as the decision of a competent tribunal, upon a subject in litigation. We can have no legitimate power to revise, or annul it.
If it were necessary to remark upon the merits of the original transaction, I should deem them, under all the circumstances, in favor of the defendant. The principles in Cowp. 200. might be fairly applied to the case.
A new trial granted.
See the same case, decided in the same way in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, an. p. 51.
Judgment was afterwards rendered for the defendant; and affirmed upon a Writ of Error in the High Court of Errors and Appeals.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.