Lessee of Sturgeon v. Waugh
Lessee of Sturgeon v. Waugh
Opinion of the Court
In England, heresay and reputation are evidenr' of boundary from the necessity of the case, (2 Term Rep. 55.1 Ld. Ray. 311) where there is no ancient terrier or map. Such evidence has also been received in Pennsylvania, though the same necessity does not subsist here in ordinary cases. But expa/rie depositions cannot be read in evidence to establish an independent title, as that one claimed under an improvement. They may also be received by way of corroboration of other testimony which has been given in the cause. Restricted and used for those purposes the two depositions may be i’ead.
As to matter of law : The limitation act of the 26th March 1785, (2 Dall. St. Laws 282) bars the right of entry or recovery on any prior warrant, whereon no survey has been made, and on any prior settlement, improvement or occupation without other title, unless there has been a possession within seven years next before the bringing of the suit.
To this it may be answered, that the caveat and decision of the two land officers, amount to other title. But a ready reply occurs, ■that their decision is merely an order of survey, and the authority not being pursued, is of no avail. Considered by itself, it vests no interest; united with an ancient occupation, long neglected and abandoned, it confers no right or title.
Admitting however, the pretensions of the lessor of the plaintiff in their fullest extent, that the fence was the original boundary, which was never altered by consent, and that the limitation act is no legal bar, still the abandonment of the improvement, and the supine negligence of Thomas for so great a length of time as thirty-six years, living at no great distance from the land, interpose insuperable obstacles to his demand.
If in England, a long possession without a deed, (2 Inst. 118, 362) is preferable to an ancient deed without possession, the rule holds with much greater force in new countries, where the community are peculiarly interested in the cultivation of the soil, and man ual labor so much enhances the value of real property. Such are
Verdict for the defendant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Lessee of Thomas Sturgeon against Alexander Waugh
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published