Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1803

Lessee of Forbes v. Caruthers

Lessee of Forbes v. Caruthers
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided May 15, 1803 · Coram, Smith, Yeates
3 Yeates 527

Lessee of Forbes v. Caruthers

Opinion of the Court

Sed per cur.

Mere abstract opinion is not evidence; but a surveyor, or any other person conversant in the subject, may state facts, and his opinion on those facts, to enable the jury to form a correct judgment of the matter in dispute. It is general information in a question of science, which others unacquainted with the subject must necessarily want. Thus a physician, who has not seen the particular patient, may, after hearing the evidence of others, be called to prove on his oath, the general effects of a particular disease, and its probable consequences in the particular case. Peake on Evid. 137.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.