Henwood v. Cheeseman
Cases that cite this one
8 later published cases cite this decision.
- In re Marriage of Kowalewski (Wash. 2008)
- In re the Marriage of Kowalewski (Wash. 2008)
- Ackerman v. Lyman (Wis. 1866)
- Croswell v. Crane (New York Supreme Court 1849)
- Croswell v. Crane (New York Supreme Court 1849)
- Whitehead v. Varnum (Mass. 1833)
- City of Boston v. Binnet (Mass. 1831)
- Butler v. Cowles (Ohio 1829)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Cheeseman, the plaintiff below, brought an action óf assumpsit against Heft-wood, for the use and occupation of the plaintiff’s land, lying in the state of New Jersey. Several exceptions were taken by the defendant to the charge of the Court, and have been assigned as errors, here. The second and fourth exceptions are not to be regarded. They are no more than complaints, that in summing up the evidence, the Court were inaccurate. With mistakes of that kind, if mistakes there were, this Court has nothing to do. In no point of View can they be considered as errors of law ; and these are the only errors of which we. have a right to take cognisance. But three errors in law, have been assigned, of which I shall proceed to take notice.
1. The act of limitations had been pleaded by the defendant. The Judge, in speaking to that point, told the jury, “ that although six years had passed, yet the defendant might “ by any conduct or language of bis, take it out of the act and then went on to explain himself more clearly, by saying, “that if the defendant had acknowledged the principal of the “ debt, and only disputed the interest, this would take the “case out of the act.” I perfectly agree with this opinion. •Much slighter acknowledgments have been held sufficient. The charge of the Court was right.
2. The Court charged, that if the defendant occupied the land, by the consent and permission of the plaintiff, the jury might presume a promise to pay a reasonable rent. In this too, the Court were clearly right. The act of assembly of Nexo Jersey is the same in substance and very nearly the
3. The last exception is, to the j urisdiction of the Court of Common Pleas. The land is in Nexo Jersey, and therefore, the defendant supposes, an action for the rent, can be main
I am of opinion, on the whole, that the present action was well brought, and well supported by the evidence. The judgment should, therefore, be affirmed.
This is an action of assumpsit for the use and occupation of a farm of the plaintiff, situated in New Jer
The pleas were non assumpsit, non assumpsit infra sex annos, and payment, to' which there were replications ; and a plea to the jurisdiction of the Court, on the ground that the action was local, the land occupied being in another state. The action of assumpsit on quantum meruit for the use and occupation of lands, lies at common law. For in Mason v. Eeldham, 3 Mod. 73, the declaration sets forth, that in consideration the plaintiff would suffer the defendant to enjoy a house, and three water mills, he proposed to pay so much yearly as they were reasonably worth, and avers that they were worth so much. On demurrer it was determined, that this action well lay, and it is said there can be no good reason given why a man may not have this action for the rent of his land as well as for his house or chamber.
It is admitted, that the act of New Jersey has the same provisions as the statute of.'ll Geo. 2. c. 19. s. 14, which provides, that where the demise is not by deed, the landlord may bring the action for the use and occupation, and if, in •evidence on the trial, any parol demise or any agreement not being by deed, wherein a certain rent was reserved, shall appear, the plaintiff thereupon shall not be non-suited, but may make use thereof as evidence of the quantum of damages tó be recovered. Thus, both by the' common law and statute law, quantum meruit for the use and occupation appears to be the specific remedy. Assumpsit for the use and occupation will lie, when the defendant enjoys by permission of, or demise from, the plaintiff. 1 Esp. 20.
The case was fairly left by the Court to the jury, to infer a contract, from the presumption arising from the occupation by the defendant; and from the defendant’s offer to pay the sum demised, without interest.
Assumpsit cannot be considered as a local action. It is founded on the contract express or implied, between the parties. No possible case could e,ver arise, in which the action would be local. But all actions of debt or covenant, between the lessor and lessee, the action being founded on privity of contract, are transitory, whether the lands be abroad, or in the county in which the action is brought. 1 Chitt. Plead. 274. The rule, as I apprehend it, is; where the action is founded on privity of estate, it is local; where on
The question on the statute of limitations, was properly left to the jury. The defendant, by his language and conduct, may take the case out of the limitation. Acknowledgments more equivocal than were made in this case, have been so submitted. He offered to pay the principal, before the magistrate. The chief difference respected the interest. An erroneous statement of facts, is not the subject of reversion in this Court. The party’s only remedy, is by application to the Co'urt below for a new trial. But, I confess, I have looked in vain for any thing in the charge of the Court, to support this objection. The fact of the occupation; and consent of the plaintiff to such occupation; the acknowledgment of the principal debt; the non-age of the defendant ; were all facts submitted to the jury for their decision.
There is no error, in the opinion of the Court, and judgment must be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.