Hussey v. White
Hussey v. White
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The question at the trial was, whether a confession of judgment de bonis entered in an amicable action against executors, is an admission of assets and conclusive in an action of debt on the judgment suggesting a devastavit; and the court was of opinion that it was not. By the English common law a judgment in this form is conclusive in all cases : but in this state it is certain that such judgments have been confessed from time immemorial \yhere the object was to subject the assets to execution without subjecting the executor to personal liability, except for an actual devastavit by evidence aliunde. We have carefully inquired’into the practice on this subject, and find it in the way I have just stated to be universal. However inconsistent with technical accuracy the use of the words in this sense may seem, there is no doubt that the parties intend by it to express their meaning to be that the assets alone shall be affected, and that to affect the executor an actual devastavit shall be proved by other evidence. According to our practice, judgment is signed by writing that word in the docket to serve as a memorandum for making up the record in form, which however is seldom if ever done: but if it were done, a general judgment against an executor not by confession, would be de bonis testatoris, or intestati, (as the case might be) according to the, form of the common law; and the suffering of such a judgment would be a conclusive admission of assets. But the nature of a judgment entered by agreement must be determined by the terms of the agreement; and by adding to the usual short entry words which are obviously designed to be, explanatory of what would otherwise be clear enough as a general judgment, the parties indicate that they did mean something else; which of course can be nothing but a special judgment operating on the assets without fixing the executor with personal liability. By any other construction the words
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HUSSEY against WHITE and another
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published