Keyser v. M'Kissan
Cases that cite this one
29 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Core5 at Route 100, LLC v. Lowhill Twp. & Lowhill Twp. Bd. of Supers. (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2026)
- Milliken v. Taylor (Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas 1935)
- Police Jury of East Baton Rouge v. Succession of McDonogh (La. 1855)
- CULCLASURE v. COMMISSIONER OF THE SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION (District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania 2020)
- In re Election Board Officers (Philadelphia County Court of Quarter Sessions 1941)
- Commonwealth Ex Rel. v. Snyder (Pa. 1928)
- Columbus Township Road (Pa. Super. Ct. 1914)
- Whitney Central Trust & Savings Bank v. Byrnes Realty Co. (La. Ct. App. 1914)
- Jordan v. Washington & Canonsburg Railway Co. (Pa. Super. Ct. 1904)
- King v. Philadelphia Co. (Pa. 1893)
- Keith v. State (Ark. 1887)
- Wells v. Taylor (Mont. 1884)
- Pooler v. Reed (Me. 1882)
- Miller v. Callaway (Ark. 1878)
- People ex rel. Steinert v. Anthony (New York Supreme Court 1875)
- Daniel v. City of New Orleans, Page & Co. (La. 1874)
- Board of Auditors v. Benoit (Mich. 1870)
- City of Philadelphia v. Given (Pa. 1869)
- Gregg Township v. Jamison (Pa. 1867)
- Harbaugh v. Winsor (Mo. 1866)
- Ex parte Strahl (Iowa 1864)
- Colton v. Beardsley, Bigelow & Spooner (New York Supreme Court 1860)
- Clark v. Commonwealth (Pa. 1858)
- Pickens v. McNutt ex rel. Kimboe (Miss. 1849)
- People v. Hopson (N.Y. 1845)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
— This is an appeal from the'decision of Justice Huston, at a Circuit Court held for the county of Franklin. The defendants move the court for a new trial, on the ground of a misdirection: 1. In instructing the jury, that the issue, whether Benjamin Keyser and Jacob Wonderlich, had taken the oath of office, was •an immaterial issue. 2. That the verdict was against law and evidence; and, 3. Because the court instructed the jury, that the plaintiffs, as commissioners, could maintain this action, without having taken the oath of office, required by the constitution of Pennsylvania. It is unnecessary to consider the first reason assigned; as, if the defendants'faii in their second and third, it will be conclusive against the application.
These were suits brought by Benjamin Keyser and others, commissioners of the county of Franklin, against the treasurer of the ■county and his sureties, on the official bond, taken in pursuance of the directions of the thirteenth section of the act of assembly of the 11th of April, 1799. It is objected, that the plaintiffs, who are the ■commissioners, and from whom the treasurer received his appointment, had not taken the oath to support the constitution; and it is strenuously contended, that this omission renders the bond void. After the decision of the court in Riddle v. The County of Bedford, we consider the oath necessary, as well in the case of the commissioners, as the treasurer. The cases are not distinguishable in principle. It must also be conceded,'as the matter now stands, that the oaths were not, in fact, taken by the commissioners. The
That the commissioners, who appointed the treasurer, were officers de facto, is certain, as they possessed every qualification of officers de jure, except in the one particular, that they had omitted taking the oath prescribed by the constitution. They had, at least, colour of title. It is equally clear, this suit is not brought for their individual benefit, but for the use of the public; for breach of the defendant’s official bond. This case is, then, embraced within all the rules settled in the various decisions cited from England, New York, and our own Reports.
An officer defacto may do such things as are for the good of the corporation. Vide King v. Lysle, Andrew’s Rep. 163. A treasurer, to receive the county monies, was indispensable. The commissioners had-the power of appointing him, and as a consequence, of exacting securityfor the faithful performance of the trust. The greater includes the less. It is a defence, not entitled to much favour on the part of the treasurer and his sureties, that the appointment is void, and in this .way to endeavour to excuse themselves from the performance of a contract; entered into with a full knowledge of all its legal consequences. Common honesty, and public policy, require that they should be estopped from such a defence.
We agree with the Circuit Court, that the verdict was according to law and the evidence; and, therefore, the judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.