Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1836

Bichel v. Rank

Bichel v. Rank
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided May 15, 1836
5 Watts 140

Bichel v. Rank

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam.

In clothing the courts with chancery powers for the adjustment of liens and distribution of money, the legislature meant not to infringe on the suitor’s constitutional right of trial by jury; and, accordingly, we find its mandate to direct an issue, where facts are in contest, is peremptory. The question to be determined, here, was exclusively a question of fact — whether the judgments in contest were collusive — which depended almost entirely on parol evidence; and the court was obviously bound to send the parties before a jury.

Decree reversed, and record remitted with directions to award an issue with precedence on the trial list.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.