Ingham v. Tracy
Ingham v. Tracy
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
The frequency of injustice from blunders in these recognizances, makes it imperatively necessary to relax the rigour of our construction of them. .It is known that our judicial records are never formally made up, and that the dockets contain but minutes, from which, however, a complete record might, in the earlier periods of our judicial history, have been formed. So far no inconvenience was felt from what was, at the time, but a wholesome departure from the extreme precision of common law precedents. The prothonotaries and clerks, holding their offices nominally at the will of the executive but actually during good behaviour, gained a competent share of skill from experience, and the records not only contained the substance of whatever was necessary to be registered, but were carefully preserved in their places. The principle of official rotation, however, has gradually excluded experience, and introduced a looseness of form sometimes unintelligible, but often requiring us to supply matter of substance from extrinsic sources for the attainment of justice; which has already produced a dangerous degree of uncertainty. From justices of the peace, however, an observance of formalities ought never to have been required. They are necessarily without official training; and their proceedings ought rather to have been expounded, where they might, in conformity to the law they were meant to execute, than in accordance to the words in which they were expressed — at least such ought to have been the rule where the entry did not purport to be a full record of all that was done, and when nothing was expressed to have been done contrary to law. There are cases where the identical words of the recognizance purport to have been set down ; and these cannot be extended by reference without involving the parties in engagements they had not consented to contract.
Judgment below reversed, and judgment for the plaintiff.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ingham against Tracy
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published