Fox v. Heffner
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
The plaintiff below claims the land under a parol agreement, between him and Morris, one of the defendants, made at the time when the sheriff’s deed conveyed the land to Morris. This was an agreement, for a violation of which the plaintiff had his remedy against Morris by his action for damages; but that it should vest in him the fee simple of the land, is directly in contravention of the Act of Assembly of the 21st of March 1772, to prevent frauds and perjuries, by which all interests in land resting in parol merely, and not put in writing, are no more
But it seems to have been thought by the court below, that the case might be taken out of the statute of frauds, on the ground that Morris was.not a purchaser in trust for Heffner, but that the real character of the transaction was a loan of money from .Morris to Heffner, and an acceptance by Morris of an absolute deed from the sheriff with a parol defeasance, thus constituting in fact a mortgage of the land from Heffner to Morris. There seems to be nothing in the evidence to justify this view of the case. In the first place, the deed wras not made from Heffner to Morris, nor could it be: all his title was devested by the sheriff’s sale. The deed was from the sheriff, who could not by law accept a mortgage of the land, nor was such a thing contemplated on his part. He was bound to make an absolute deed to the purchaser of all the title of the debtor in the land. The truth of the case evidently is, that Morris took Patterson’s place as purchaser at the sheriff’s sale, and received the deed from the sheriff in that capacity, and could receive it in no other, without violating the Acts of Assembly for the sale of lands by execution.
In the next place, there is no evidence that Morris lent the money to Heffner. Heffner did not receive the money nor pay it over. It was Morris that paid the sheriff with his own money, and furnished the consideration of the sheriff’s deed, in lieu of Patterson. Morris told Miller he had advanced the money for Heffner, and that Heffner was to have the property whenever he
There are several circumstances in this case tending to prove it inequitable, that the plaintiff should now recover this property, were it free from the insuperable objection of the Act of Assembly. The parol contract appears to have been made in April 1834. Morris then went into possession, and afterwards in vain demanded his money of the plaintiff. It was not till March 1837, three years afterwards, that the plaintiff tendered the money to Heffner, after the latter had sold the property. This was a delay of two years beyond the time limited, during which the plaintiff took the chance of the rise or fall of the property. Morris was not bound to lie out of his money. In the meanwhile Morris had articled to sell the property to Koch & Zimmerman, on the 7th of September 1836, and received twenty-five dollars on the sale; and on the 18th of December 1836, they assigned to Mrs. Fox, who received a deed on the 3d of April 1837, (when by the articles the money was to be paid) and made improvements between that time and the 20th of October 1837, to the amount of from thirty to fifty dollars. It was not till December 1837, that the plaintiff tendered her #202, and requested her to execute a deed to him. This she refused, saying she held or looked to Morris for the property. It would, we think, be unjust to take away the property under these circumstances, from Mrs. Fox, who had expended her money on the faith of the deed to Morris, as well as his possession, and his article with Koch & Zimmerman, and to vest it in one who had been guilty of so much laches.
We are, therefore, of opinion, that the court below erred in their charge to the jury, and that the judgment must be reversed.
Judgment reversed, and venire facias de novo awarded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.