Dixon v. Ramage
Dixon v. Ramage
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
It is unnecessary to examine several of the subjects discussed in this case, because we are clearly of opinion, that under the will of Samuel Ramage, the defendant, Jonathan Ramage, took only an estate during the widowhood of his mother, and not an estate in fee, as the court below considered it. The devise by the testator of his property, real and personal, is “ to my wife Mary and. son Jonathan, share and share alike, so long as she remains my widow.” This is an express estate to them
In the present instance, the testator would seem to have contemplated that the wife would survive long enough to raise the family, for that charge is imposed on her as well as Jonathan. In that event, Jonathan’s estate would continue till the children were paid off, and might possibly extend beyond it. We cannot perceive any thing in the will to show that the testator intended that Jonathan should have the whole estate after the wife’s death or marriage, and the other children have no part of it except their legacies on arriving at age. The dispositions of the will may not perhaps be reconcileable with exact justice to all, — but that was a matter of which the testator had a right to judge for himself — we can do no more than construe that which is brought before us. If the conditions were as onerous to Jonathan as they are stated to have been, he had the right to renounce them, which in fact it is alleged he did. The will, however, is so drawn, that he could take no larger interest in the real estate than the widow herself, with whom he was associated as tenant in common. On her death it ceased; the testator, as to the residue, died intestate, and the plaintiffs are entitled as heirs at law, claiming by descent.
We perceive no error in admitting in evidence the record of the action of partition, so far as respects two of the present plaintiffs, who were parties to it. There is no question raised on
Judgment reversed, and a venire facias ele novo awarded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Dixon against Ramage
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published