Drexel v. Man
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Commonwealth v. Donnelly (Pa. Super. Ct. 1909)
- Birmingham Fire Insurance v. Commonwealth ex rel. Kuehneisen (Pa. 1879)
- Commonwealth v. Hultz (Pa. 1847)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
It is sffange that the writ of mandamus should still be supposed to give remedy in a case like the present. It is true that it does so in New York, as appears by The People v. The Judges of Washington County, (2 Caines’ R. 97), the secret of which is, that the matter is regulated there by a particular statute of the state. I have seen no case, English or American, which indicates that it may be used for the purpose as a prerogative writ. In England it certainly may not; for we are told by Lord Coke, (2 Inst. 426), that the proper remedy is a writ specially framed on the stat. Westm. 2; and accordingly we find a form for it in the Register, page 182, setting forth the circumstances of the case, and commanding the judges, if they be true, to affix their seals to the bill. If they return that they are untrue, the superior court proceeds no further, but leaves the complainant to his action for a false return, in which their truth is tried according to the course of the common law. Such a remedy certainly resembles an alternative mandamus; still it is not a prerogative writ, but specific, grounded on a statute. That no instance of its use is to be found, was said by counsel in Bridgman v. Holt, (Show. P. C. 122), to be because no English judge had ever refused to allow a proper exception. However that may be, recourse might certainly be had to it there, and a writ might be framed in conformity to it here. But if we have no precedent for an actual recourse to it, neither have we a precedent for a successful recourse to a mandamus as a substitute for it. In place of that, it was very seriously doubted in The Commonwealth v. The Judges of the Common Pleas, (3 Binn. 273); The Same v. The Same, (1 Serg. & Rawle 187); Morris v. Buckley, (8 Serg. & Rawle 211); and in Kolb’s Case, (4 Watts 154), whether a mandamus lies to a county court for any purpose whatever. The point has not been decided, nor is it necessary to decide it now; for it has never been sup
Rule discharged.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.