M'Kinney v. Mehaffey
Cases that cite this one
11 later published cases cite this decision.
- Commonwealth v. Great American Indemnity Co. (Pa. 1933)
- Automobile Securities Co. v. Wilson (Pa. 1928)
- Goller v. Wass's Administrator (Somerset County Court of Common Pleas 1927)
- Blue Star Navigation Co. v. Emmons Coal Mining Corp. (Pa. 1923)
- Markee v. Philadelphia (Pa. 1921)
- Vamos ex rel. Adams v. Tabachnick (Northampton County Court of Common Pleas 1921)
- Massey v. Massey (Pa. 1920)
- Campbell's Estate (Pa. Super. Ct. 1903)
- Ernst's Estate (Pa. 1894)
- Oil City v. Hartwell (Pa. 1894)
- Withers' Appeal (Pa. 1850)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
A scire facias answers the purpose both of a writ and a declaration; and where a legal title to have execution of the original judgment or recognizance is not set out in it, judgment may be arrested as for want of a cause of action. But execution is to be had only in the name of the legal plaintiff; and what title to the character does this plaintiff show ? He has set out the judgment truly as it exists; and as there was no variance between his description and the truth, there was no room for the plea of nul tiel record. There is exactly such a record as is stated in the scire facias; but it stands as a judgment recovered by Henry Share & Co., and the plaintiff insists that it is a judgment recovered by the firm, which entitles him to execution in his own name as surviving partner. But it would be inconsistent with the
The motion to set aside the original judgment is not a ground of error; and, if it were, it is far from clear that it ought to have prevailed after the lapse of twenty years, when the witnesses who might have explained the reason of the interlineations must be presumed to have passed away. If the facts were doubtful, it would be in the discretion of the court to award an issue; but it certainly would be rash to destroy the foundation of the scire facias by a summary interference in the trial of an issue raised by the pleadings under it.-
It is unnecessary to decide the questions raised by the bills of exceptions; but it is not improper to say that we perceive no error in the admission of evidence, or the direction to the jury.
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.