Bosler v. Kuhn
Cases that cite this one
19 later published cases cite this decision.
- Pronzato v. Guerrina (Pa. 1960)
- In re Girard Trust Co. (Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas 1939)
- Royal Ins. Co. v. Smith (9th Cir. 1935)
- Crowley v. Potts (Minn. 1930)
- Provident Trust Co. v. Commissioner (United States Board of Tax Appeals 1927)
- Van Beil v. Brogan (Pa. Super. Ct. 1917)
- Bowler v. Emery (R.I. 1908)
- Wilson v. Iseminger (Supreme Court of the United States 1902)
- Klein v. W. A. Gavenesch Co. (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1902)
- Weinmann & Co.'s Estate (Pa. 1894)
- Deane v. Caldwell (Mass. 1879)
- Ex parte Houghton (District Court, D. Massachusetts 1871)
- Davis v. Burton (Pa. 1866)
- Laughlin v. Harvey (Pa. 1865)
- Hipple v. Rice (Pa. 1857)
- Bennett v. Bartlett (Mass. 1850)
- Juvenal v. Patterson (Pa. 1849)
- Savory v. Stocking (Mass. 1849)
- Prentiss v. Kingsley (Pa. 1848)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
The fifth section of the late American Bankrupt Law, which designated the classes of provable debts, contained no provision for a ground-rent covenant in terms. It was said that creditors whose debts were payable at a future day, annuitants, holders of bottomry and respondentia bonds, and of policies of insurance, sureties, endorsers, bail, or persons having contingent demands against the bankrupts, might prove such debts and have them allowed when they became absolute; and that annuitants and holders of debts payable in futuri, might have the present value ascertained and allowed as debts in presentí: whence an argument that a ground-rent covenant was provable as an annuity, or at least as a future debt; to the one or the other of which it certainly bears more resemblance than to any other class in the catalogue. Previous to the 49 Geo. 3, c. 121, since merged in the 6 Geo. 4, c. 16, from which this specific provision of the American statute was taken, even an annuity was not provable when ^not secured by a forfeited annuity bond, which enabled the courts to let the annuitant in to prove as a creditor for the penalty taken by a legal subtlety to be the debt at law. An annuitant, however, is now let in by force of the special provision there, as he was here; and unless a ground-rent covenant were treated as an annuity, the landlord could not have proved, and the tenant cannot
An annuity is discharged by the death of the grantor; a ground-rent covenant is perpetual. By the statute, an annuity might have been valued and the annuitant let in to prove as a creditor to the extent of the valuation, as he may by the 6 Geo. 4; but to value such a covenant, which is perpetual, as an annuity which expires with the grantor, would wrong the ground landlord, who has a fee-simple in the rent, and consequently a perpetual interest in the covenant to secure it. It would be impossible to treat such a covenant consistently as an annuity in substance and a covenant in form. It might be practicable to value it at so many years’ purchase; but it would be valued as a rent, and not as an annuity. The statute seems to have contemplated nothing of the sort; for the covenant is but an accessory, the rent being the principal,
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.