Sample v. Coulson
Cases that cite this one
6 later published cases cite this decision.
- Security Trust Co. v. Feist (Pa. 1938)
- Gates v. Keichline (Pa. 1925)
- Flynn v. Kalamazoo Circuit Judge (Mich. 1904)
- Levi v. Evans (7th Cir. 1893)
- Splahn v. Gillespie (Ind. 1874)
- McGinity v. McGinity (Pa. 1870)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
The principal question in this case arises on the 1st and 2d errors, embracing the 4th and 5th bills of exception. The present suit was brought by William Coulson in his own right to recover 35 acres of land which he claimed under a deed made to him in December 1840, by T. S. Williamson, whose title was derived from a sale by the executor of Patrick Scott, by order of the Orphans’Court,on the petition of Scott’s heirs in March 1839. A former ejectment had been brought to November 1829, in the Common Pleas of York county, by William Coulson, as surviving executor of Patrick Scott, deceased, against John Sample, Cunningham Sample and Joseph M. Sample, on which a verdict passed for the defendants in August 1833. On that trial the court instructed the jury that Patrick Scott died intestate as to the land in dispute, and that on his death it went to his heirs and not to his executors; consequently their verdict must be for the defendants. On the present trial, the plaintiff offered and the court admitted the verdict and judgment in evidence, and also the testimony given by John Evans, Esq., of the evidence of Richard Porter, since deceased, proving a draft identified by him as having been made by Richard Porter, with a survey at the instance of the administrators of John Sample; also, that T. Kelly, since deceased, was a witness, and that on his examination the defendant’s counsel admitted that the draft was the one referred to in the deed.
It would rather seem, from a consideration of the authorities and legal principles on this subject, that the evidence was not admissible. To make a former verdict and the testimony then given evidence in a subsequent trial, it must be between the same parties or their privies, and in relation to the same title. It was competent to the defendants in the former suit to fold their hands as to everything else, and rely upon the incapacity of the plaintiff to recover, and it was upon that ground alone the case was decided. It would not be fair to implicate the defendants at a future day in points which they were not legally bound to regard, and concerning which, though they may have been at liberty to cross-examine, they were not under any obligation to do so, it being
The 6th exception has been but little relied upon, and we think there is nothing in it. The writ filed in the office became thereby a record of the office, and must rightly be taken to have been signed by the sheriff, as it purported to be, nor could parol evidence be received to contradict it.
The 7th and 8th bills of exceptions were taken to the rejection
11th bill. Nor can the intent or design of the purchaser to take the land for the use of third persons be entered into by evidence other than writing, where the case does not fall within those exceptions which equity has established, and which have been adverted to. '
But for the first'two errors assigned the judgment is reversed, and a venire facias de novo is awarded.
Judgment reversed, and a venire facias de novo awarded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.