Commonwealth v. Reitzel
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Saint Paul Mercury Indemnity Co.'s Appeal (Pa. 1937)
- Commonwealth v. Sweigart (Pa. Super. Ct. 1899)
- Merchants' Warehouse Co. v. Gelder (Pa. 1944)
- Mercer County v. Cantelupe (Et Al.) (Pa. 1941)
- Pennsylvania Co. v. Finance Realty Corp. (Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas 1938)
- Riehl v. Miller (Pa. 1934)
- Wm. Wilson & Son Silversmith Co.'s Estate (Pa. 1892)
- Pardee v. Markle (Pa. 1886)
- McMicken v. Commonwealth (Pa. 1868)
- Philadelphia v. Commonwealth (Pa. 1866)
- Manufacturers' & Mechanics' Savings & Loan Co. v. Odd Fellows' Hall Asso'n (Pa. 1865)
- McKee's v. Commonwealth (Pa. 1853)
- Commonwealth v. Easton Bank (Pa. 1849)
- Hutchinson v. Commonwealth (Pa. 1847)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
This action was instituted in the court below by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania against the defendant, Philip Reitzel, upon his bond as one of the sureties of Frederick Ham-bright, late collector of tolls at Lancaster,, to recover two several
It is very apparent from the various provisions of the act, that the Legislature intended to make a settlement of the accounts mentioned in it by the Auditor General and State Treasurer in the manner therein directed, final and conclusive unless appealed from within the time allowed by the Act for that purpose, and conclusive, too, as I conceive, upon the sureties, though the right of appeal, as it appears to me, is only given to the principal debtors. But then, in order to make it binding and conclusive upon the surety, it ought to appear in some way that it is exclusively applicable to the time for which he was bound as surety, and not made to include accounts against the principal debtor which accrued either before the suretyship of the defendant commenced, or after it ceased. To make a surety responsible for moneys received by the principal, it ought to be that they were received, at least, during the time for which the obligation of his suretyship made him answerable as such. For it is not the settlement of the account alone that renders him liable; his obligation lies at the bottom of his liability, and if the accounts charged against the principal are not embraced by the obligation of the surety, it is very clear that the latter cannot be made liable by any thing that the Auditor General and State Treasurer can do, who are expressly required to adjust and settle the account according to law and equity. The evidence, therefore, objected to was admissible, for the purpose of showing that the money demanded of the defendant in this action, and charged to his principal in his general account by the Auditor General and State Treasurer, was not received by the principal during the time for which the defendant
It is also alleged that the court below erred in admitting Ham-bright himself to testify on behalf of the defendant; that he was interested in the event of the suit, and therefore incompetent. The defendant, before he adduced Hambright as a witness on his behalf, executed and delivered to him a release, discharging him from all liability that he might be under to him, for and on account of the costs to which he, the defendant, might be subjected, and have to pay in this action. This, as it would appear, is the only interest which Hambright had or could have in this suit; for his liability to the Commonwealth for the payment of the debt that might be recovered from the defendant in this action, was at least as strong and as certain as any liability he was under to the defendant to keep him indemnified, or to reimburse him in case he should be compelled to pay it, could be. As between the Commonwealth and the defendant, he stood indifferent as regarded the debt owing by him to the Commonwealth. He was bound to pay it, at all events, either to the Commonwealth, or if the defendant was made to pay it for him, then to the latter. But, in no event of this suit, whether the result should be in favour of or against the defendant, could the liability of Hambright be diminished or increased, except as to the costs of it, from which he was released. The verdict and judgment in this action could not be made evidence, either for or against Plambright, in an action brought by the Commonwealth against him to recover the debt claimed here. It is clear, therefore, that after being released by the defendant from all claim which the latter might or should have against him, at any time, for or on account of the costs of this suit, he could not be affected in any way whatever by the result of it, and consequently was competent to give testimony.
There are also exceptions to the answers given by the court to certain points submitted by the counsel for the Commonwealth, in which it is alleged that the court erred. By the first point the court was requested to instruct the jury, that as the defendant had neglected to attend to the settlement of Mr. Hambright’s account, or had not appealed therefrom, after it was settled, in the manner prescribed by the 11th section of the Act recited above, the settlement, as made, became binding and conclusive on all the parties, as well the sureties as the principal, and therefore could not be contradicted or impeached in this suit, or inquired into collaterally. To which the court answered, that the fact of the defendant’s not having attended to the settlement of Mr. Ham-bright’s account, nor having appealed therefrom, could not preclude him from showing that the very moneys received by the collector, after the bond of the 19th April 1843, (meaning the bond in suit,) were all paid over to the State Treasurer, and availing himself of that circumstance, so far as it has been proved,
In opposition then to principles so equitable and just, it is not to be supposed that the account of Mr Hambright, as stated by the Auditor General, which was a general account, embracing the whole time that he bad been in office, from 1839 to 1844, though appointed and reappointed annually, when new bonds and sureties were given for each year, was designed to show the actual liability of the different sets of sureties under their respective bonds. The form and manner of making out and stating the account shows nothing_of the kind, and could not possibly have been intended to show it, for it shows most clearly the contrary on its face. Had such been the intention, a separate and distinct account would have been made out and stated for each year, commencing with the date of the appointment or reappointment for the same, and showing the moneys received and paid away during each year. Had this been done, I have not a doubt but the sureties respectively for each year would have been bound and concluded by the settlement, if not appealed from within due time. But the account being made out in the form of a general account current, commencing with the year 1839 and closing with the year 1843-4, throws the accumulated balance for this whole period upon the defendant, who was surety only for the last year. This would be so abhorrent to every principle of justice, and even contrary to what was intended, as it wyuld appear from the form and manner of stating and settling the account, that it can and ought not to be allowed or sanctioned.
The discussion of this first point, submitted to the court below, and the principles referred to and brought to bear upon it, solve the questions raised in the second and third points, the answers to which were excepted to. It is therefore unnecessary to notice them specially.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.