Sterling v. Stewart
Sterling v. Stewart
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered, March 2d 1874, by
The plaintiff below — the defendant in error— lent to Cooper & Sterling $500 — $250 to each — and took from them a joint and several note or obligation, under seal, for the whole amount, payable one day after date, upon which this suit was brought. Under the instructions of the court, the jury found that the defendant, Sterling, did not sign the note, as alleged, in pursuance of a promise on the part of the plaintiff that if he would sign it he would not hold him for more than the half of it. He was therefore clearly liable for one-half of the note as principal debtor, and for the remaining half as the surety of Cooper, his copromissor. He paid, as is admitted, the one-half of the note, and he insists that he is discharged from his liability for the residue because the plaintiff agreed that if he would pay it, he would give him a receipt in full for his half of the note; and when ho paid it, the plaintiff gave him such a receipt. Was this a release or discharge of his liability as surety for the residue of the note ? Why should it be, if the plaintiff did not promise or agree to acquit or release him from his liability? No such promise or undertaking is suggested in the 'point submitted by the defendant, the refusal of which is assigned as error; nor can it be inferred or implied from the facts of which it is predicated. The court was asked to charge “ that, if the jury believe that Stewart told Sterling that if he could pay his half of the note that he would give him a receipt in full for his half of .the note; and that Sterling then paid him the one-half of the note and interest, - and Stewart gave him a receipt therefor, in which he stated ‘ that it was in full for his half of the note given by Cooper and Sterling to A. P. Stewart,’ the plaintiff is not entitled to recover.” What, then, did the plaintiff
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.