Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1879

Hutchison v. Gill

Hutchison v. Gill
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided October 20, 1879 · No. 73 · Gordon, Green, Merour, Paxson, Sharswood, Sterrett, Trunkey
91 Pa. 253; 1879 Pa. LEXIS 331

Counsel

Robert Pollock and Thomas M. Marshall, for plaintiff in error., M. W. Acheson, for defendants in error. —

Hutchison v. Gill

Opinion of the Court

The judgment of the Supreme Court was entered,

Per Curiam.

When a mortgagor, at the same time that he executes a mortgage, delivers to the mortgagee a writing, certifying that he has no defence or defalcation, it is in effect an agreement that the mortgagee shall negotiate the mortgage. It is an acknowledgment that he has received full consideration. It is indeed most usual to execute such writings when no consideration has been received, and the sole object of the mortgage is to raise money by the sale of it. It would be in the highest degree inequitable to allow the mortgagor to set up that there was fraud in obtaining the mortgage, or in a misappropriation by the mortgagee of the money raised by the sale. It is unnecessary to say what would be the effect of actual fraud in procuring the “ no defence” paper. In this case there was no evidence of such fraud.

Judgment affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.